Math Problem Statement
Let g : R → R be continuous function taking values in Q. Then show that g is a constant function.
Solution
To show that if is a continuous function that only takes values in (the set of rational numbers), then must be a constant function, we can use the following reasoning:
Proof by Contradiction
-
Assume is not constant:
Suppose, for contradiction, that is not a constant function. Then there exist two points and in such that: Since takes values only in , this implies that , and these values are distinct rational numbers. -
Continuity of :
The function is given as continuous. By the intermediate value theorem (a fundamental result of real analysis), if a function is continuous on an interval and takes two different values at two points, it must take every value between those two points. This means that for any real numbers and with , the function must take every value in the interval . -
Contradiction with the rationals:
The rational numbers are not dense in the real numbers in the sense of continuity: there are irrational numbers between any two distinct rational numbers. Thus, if were to take every value between and , it would need to take irrational values as well, contradicting the assumption that only takes values in . -
Conclusion:
The only way for a continuous function to take values only in , a set that is "sparse" in (in the sense that it does not contain any interval), is for the function to be constant. Hence, must be a constant function.
Final Answer:
The function that takes values only in and is continuous must be a constant function.
Do you have any questions or want further details?
Here are 5 related questions:
- What is the intermediate value theorem?
- Can a function take irrational values and still be continuous?
- What are some other examples of continuous but non-constant functions?
- How do we define continuity for a function from ?
- Can a function that only takes rational values ever be discontinuous?
Tip: The intermediate value theorem is a powerful tool in analysis, especially when working with continuous functions. Familiarizing yourself with its applications can help in solving a wide range of problems.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Continuity
Real Analysis
Intermediate Value Theorem
Rational Numbers
Formulas
-
Theorems
Intermediate Value Theorem
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate Math (Real Analysis)
Related Recommendation
Proof of Function Equality on Interval Using Continuity and Rational Density
Continuity and Rational Numbers: Proving f(x) = 0 for all x in (a, b)
Solve the Cauchy Functional Equation f(x + y) = f(x) + f(y)
Functional Equation Problem: Show Existence of Solutions for f(α) = g(α)
Isometry Proof: Functions of the Form f(x) = x + a or f(x) = -x + a