Math Problem Statement
Find the smallest value of m so that the following statement is valid: Any collection of m distinct positive integers must contain at least two numbers whose sum or difference is a multiple of 10. Prove that your value is best possible.
Solution
We are tasked with finding the smallest value of such that any collection of distinct positive integers contains at least two numbers whose sum or difference is divisible by 10. Let's break the problem into manageable steps:
Step 1: Modular Arithmetic Setup
Consider the numbers modulo 10. Every integer can be written as , where . So, for any collection of integers, their behavior modulo 10 is central to the problem. We are interested in when the sum or difference of two numbers is divisible by 10. This occurs when:
This translates to:
- if the remainders of and modulo 10 add up to 10 (or 0 for identical remainders).
- if , i.e., the remainders are the same.
Step 2: Analyze the Remainders
The numbers modulo 10 are . To ensure that no two numbers in a collection sum or differ by a multiple of 10, we need to avoid:
- Any two numbers having the same remainder modulo 10 (this would give ).
- Any two numbers whose remainders add up to 10, i.e., pairs like .
Thus, we need to carefully select remainders such that no two remainders are the same and no two remainders add up to 10.
Step 3: Maximize the Collection Without Violating the Conditions
We will now try to form the largest collection of distinct remainders modulo 10 that satisfies these conditions:
- Choose remainders and , but we can only select one of each, as adding two 's or two 's would violate the difference condition.
- For the other remainders, avoid pairing remainders that sum to 10. This allows us to choose one element from each pair of remainders:
- Choose either or , but not both.
- Choose either or , but not both.
- Choose either or , but not both.
- Choose either or , but not both.
Thus, the largest set of remainders we can select without violating the sum or difference condition consists of 5 elements:
Step 4: Conclusion
If we try to include more than 5 numbers, there will be at least two numbers whose sum or difference is divisible by 10. Hence, is the smallest value for which the condition is violated, since for any collection of 6 distinct numbers modulo 10, at least two of them must either have the same remainder or sum to 10.
Therefore, the smallest value of is , and this is the best possible value because any collection of 5 numbers can be chosen without violating the conditions, but any collection of 6 will always violate the condition.
Relative Questions:
- What is the principle of modular arithmetic and how is it applied in this problem?
- How can the concept of remainder classes modulo 10 be used to solve other similar problems?
- Can this approach be generalized for sums and differences divisible by numbers other than 10?
- What happens if we change the number base (e.g., modulo 12 instead of modulo 10)?
- What alternative strategies can be used to find patterns when dealing with sums and differences in integer sets?
Tip:
Modular arithmetic is a powerful tool when dealing with problems involving divisibility or cyclic patterns in numbers. Always consider simplifying complex conditions with modulo operations to spot hidden symmetries.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Modular Arithmetic
Combinatorics
Number Theory
Formulas
x + y ≡ 0 (mod 10)
x - y ≡ 0 (mod 10)
Theorems
Pigeonhole Principle
Modular Arithmetic Properties
Suitable Grade Level
Grades 10-12
Related Recommendation
Smallest N for Distinct Pairwise Sums with All Units Digits
Find the Smallest Non-Zero Natural Number for Modulo 8 and 10 Conditions
Dirichlet's Theorem and Modulo Arithmetic: Divisibility of 19 Numbers
Find the Last Two Digits of the Smallest 5-Digit Number Satisfying Modular Conditions
Finding the Smallest Value of a + b Given Divisibility Conditions