Math Problem Statement

Define a relation on Z as aRb if 3 | (5a − 8b). Is R an equivalence relation? Justify your answer

Solution

To determine whether RR is an equivalence relation, we must verify if it satisfies the three properties of equivalence relations: reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity.


Definition of RR:

A relation RR on Z\mathbb{Z} (the set of integers) is defined as: aRb    3(5a8b),a R b \iff 3 \mid (5a - 8b), where 3x3 \mid x means that xx is divisible by 3.


1. Reflexivity

A relation RR is reflexive if aRaa R a for all aZa \in \mathbb{Z}.

aRa    3(5a8a)=3a.a R a \iff 3 \mid (5a - 8a) = 3a.

Since 3a3a is always divisible by 3 for any integer aa, RR is reflexive.


2. Symmetry

A relation RR is symmetric if aRb    bRaa R b \implies b R a.

Suppose aRba R b, which means: 3(5a8b).3 \mid (5a - 8b).

Then, there exists an integer kk such that: 5a8b=3k.5a - 8b = 3k.

We need to check whether bRab R a, which means: 3(5b8a).3 \mid (5b - 8a).

Compute 5b8a5b - 8a in terms of 5a8b5a - 8b: 5b8a=(5a8b).5b - 8a = -(5a - 8b).

Since 3(5a8b)3 \mid (5a - 8b), it follows that 3(5a8b)3 \mid -(5a - 8b). Therefore, 3(5b8a)3 \mid (5b - 8a), and bRab R a. Thus, RR is symmetric.


3. Transitivity

A relation RR is transitive if aRba R b and bRc    aRcb R c \implies a R c.

Suppose aRba R b and bRcb R c. Then: 3(5a8b)and3(5b8c).3 \mid (5a - 8b) \quad \text{and} \quad 3 \mid (5b - 8c).

This means there exist integers k1k_1 and k2k_2 such that: 5a8b=3k1and5b8c=3k2.5a - 8b = 3k_1 \quad \text{and} \quad 5b - 8c = 3k_2.

Add these two equations: (5a8b)+(5b8c)=3k1+3k2.(5a - 8b) + (5b - 8c) = 3k_1 + 3k_2.

Simplify: 5a8c=3(k1+k2).5a - 8c = 3(k_1 + k_2).

Since 3(5a8c)3 \mid (5a - 8c), aRca R c. Thus, RR is transitive.


Conclusion

The relation RR satisfies reflexivity, symmetry, and transitivity. Therefore, RR is an equivalence relation.


Questions:

  1. Can you provide an example to verify the transitivity of this relation using specific integers?
  2. How would the properties change if the divisor were a number other than 3 (e.g., 4 or 5)?
  3. Why does the symmetry property depend on the additive structure of integers?
  4. How does divisibility ensure reflexivity for this specific relation?
  5. Can RR partition Z\mathbb{Z} into equivalence classes? If so, what do the equivalence classes look like?

Tip:

When checking equivalence relations, always try verifying the properties with small, concrete examples to build intuition.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Relations
Equivalence Relations
Divisibility
Properties of Relations

Formulas

3 | (5a - 8b)

Theorems

Reflexivity
Symmetry
Transitivity

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 11-12