Math Problem Statement

Suppose p is a relation defined on the set Z,

p = {(x,y) EZxZ)(xy)is divisible by 3), then pis

(A) Reflexive but not Symmetric, Transitive

(B) Reflexive, Symmetric but not Transitive

(C) Reflexive. Transitive but not Symmetric (D) Equivalence

Solution

Given the relation p={(x,y)Z×Zxy is divisible by 3}p = \{(x, y) \in \mathbb{Z} \times \mathbb{Z} \mid xy \text{ is divisible by 3}\} defined on the set of integers Z\mathbb{Z}, we need to determine the properties of this relation—whether it is reflexive, symmetric, transitive, or an equivalence relation.

1. Reflexive:

A relation pp is reflexive if (x,x)p(x, x) \in p for all xZx \in \mathbb{Z}, meaning xxx \cdot x is divisible by 3.

  • For pp to be reflexive, we need xxx \cdot x to be divisible by 3 for every xZx \in \mathbb{Z}.
  • However, not every integer satisfies x2x^2 divisible by 3. Only integers divisible by 3 satisfy this condition.

Thus, p is not reflexive.

2. Symmetric:

A relation pp is symmetric if whenever (x,y)p(x, y) \in p, then (y,x)p(y, x) \in p as well, i.e., if xyxy is divisible by 3, then yxyx must also be divisible by 3.

  • Since multiplication is commutative (xy=yxxy = yx), if xyxy is divisible by 3, so is yxyx.

Thus, p is symmetric.

3. Transitive:

A relation pp is transitive if whenever (x,y)p(x, y) \in p and (y,z)p(y, z) \in p, then (x,z)p(x, z) \in p as well, i.e., if xyxy and yzyz are divisible by 3, then xzxz should also be divisible by 3.

  • This does not always hold. For instance, if x=3x = 3, y=1y = 1, and z=3z = 3, then xy=3x \cdot y = 3 (divisible by 3) and yz=3y \cdot z = 3 (divisible by 3), but xz=9x \cdot z = 9 is divisible by 3. However, if y=2y = 2, neither xzx \cdot z nor xyx \cdot y might be divisible by 3, breaking the transitivity.

Thus, p is not transitive.

Conclusion:

From the analysis, the relation is symmetric but neither reflexive nor transitive. Therefore, the correct answer is:

(B) Reflexive, Symmetric but not Transitive.


Would you like any additional clarification or details on this problem? Here are a few related questions for further practice:

  1. What is an example of a reflexive relation that is also symmetric?
  2. Can you provide a set where the relation pp would be reflexive?
  3. What is the difference between transitive and symmetric relations?
  4. If a relation is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive, what is it called?
  5. How does the property of symmetry relate to commutative operations?

Tip: Always check symmetry and reflexivity using small examples for clarity, especially when dealing with multiplication or divisibility relations.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Relations
Properties of Relations
Divisibility
Symmetry
Reflexivity
Transitivity

Formulas

-

Theorems

Properties of Relations Theorem
Divisibility Rules

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-12