Math Problem Statement

Show that ||x| − |y|| ≤ |x − y| without using the triangle inequality

Solution

To prove that xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| without using the triangle inequality, we can proceed as follows:

Let's denote xx and yy as real numbers.

Case 1: xy0x \geq y \geq 0 or yx0y \geq x \geq 0

Assume xy0x \geq y \geq 0. Then:

x=x,y=y,andxy=xy|x| = x, \quad |y| = y, \quad \text{and} \quad |x - y| = x - y

So, the left side of the inequality becomes:

xy=xy||x| - |y|| = |x - y|

In this case, the inequality xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| holds as an equality.

Case 2: x0x \geq 0 and y0y \leq 0 (or vice versa)

Assume x0x \geq 0 and y0y \leq 0. Then:

x=xandy=y|x| = x \quad \text{and} \quad |y| = -y

So, the expression for xy||x| - |y|| becomes:

xy=x(y)=x+y||x| - |y|| = |x - (-y)| = |x + y|

The right side, xy|x - y|, is:

xy|x - y|

Now, since x0x \geq 0 and y0y \leq 0, it is easy to see that:

x+yxy|x + y| \leq |x - y|

Thus, the inequality xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| holds.

Case 3: x0x \leq 0 and y0y \leq 0

Assume x0x \leq 0 and y0y \leq 0. Then:

x=xandy=y|x| = -x \quad \text{and} \quad |y| = -y

So:

xy=x+y=yx||x| - |y|| = |-x + y| = |y - x|

And:

xy=(x)(y)=yx|x - y| = |(-x) - (-y)| = |y - x|

Thus, the inequality xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| holds as an equality in this case as well.

Case 4: yx0y \geq x \geq 0 (Reverse of Case 1)

This case is symmetric to Case 1 and follows the same logic.

Conclusion

In all cases, the inequality xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| holds. This concludes the proof.


Would you like more details on any part of the proof?

Here are some related questions you might be interested in:

  1. Can you provide an example where xy=xy||x| - |y|| = |x - y|?
  2. What is the geometric interpretation of xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y|?
  3. How does the triangle inequality compare to this inequality?
  4. Is the inequality xyxy||x| - |y|| \leq |x - y| strict or can it be an equality?
  5. How would the proof change if xx and yy were vectors instead of real numbers?

Tip: When dealing with absolute values, breaking down the problem into cases based on the signs of the variables often simplifies the proof.