Math Problem Statement

if (an) and (bn) are bounded sequences and liman=a>0 and limsupbn=b then show that limsup(an+bn)=a+b

Solution

To prove that lim sup(an+bn)=a+b\limsup(a_n + b_n) = a + b given that (an)(a_n) and (bn)(b_n) are bounded sequences, liman=a>0\lim a_n = a > 0, and lim supbn=b\limsup b_n = b, we'll proceed with the following steps:

Definitions and Assumptions

  1. Bounded Sequences: Both (an)(a_n) and (bn)(b_n) are bounded.
  2. Convergence of (an)(a_n): liman=a>0\lim a_n = a > 0.
  3. Limit Superior of (bn)(b_n): lim supbn=b\limsup b_n = b.

Proof

Step 1: Limiting Behavior of (an)(a_n)

Since liman=a>0\lim a_n = a > 0, for any ϵ>0\epsilon > 0, there exists an N1N_1 such that for all n>N1n > N_1: ana<ϵ.|a_n - a| < \epsilon. This implies: aϵ<an<a+ϵ.a - \epsilon < a_n < a + \epsilon.

Step 2: Upper Bound of (bn)(b_n)

By the definition of lim supbn=b\limsup b_n = b, for any ϵ>0\epsilon > 0, there exists an N2N_2 such that for all n>N2n > N_2: bn<b+ϵ.b_n < b + \epsilon. Also, there exist infinitely many indices nn such that bn>bϵb_n > b - \epsilon.

Step 3: Combining Limits for (an+bn)(a_n + b_n)

  • Upper Bound: For n>max(N1,N2)n > \max(N_1, N_2), an+bn<(a+ϵ)+(b+ϵ)=a+b+2ϵ.a_n + b_n < (a + \epsilon) + (b + \epsilon) = a + b + 2\epsilon. Therefore, lim sup(an+bn)a+b+2ϵ.\limsup (a_n + b_n) \leq a + b + 2\epsilon. Since ϵ\epsilon can be arbitrarily small, lim sup(an+bn)a+b.\limsup (a_n + b_n) \leq a + b.

  • Lower Bound: Consider the infinitely many indices for which bn>bϵb_n > b - \epsilon and combine them with the bounds for ana_n: For these indices and n>max(N1,N2)n > \max(N_1, N_2), an+bn>(aϵ)+(bϵ)=a+b2ϵ.a_n + b_n > (a - \epsilon) + (b - \epsilon) = a + b - 2\epsilon. Therefore, lim sup(an+bn)a+b2ϵ.\limsup (a_n + b_n) \geq a + b - 2\epsilon.

Since ϵ\epsilon can be arbitrarily small, lim sup(an+bn)a+b.\limsup (a_n + b_n) \geq a + b.

Conclusion

From the inequalities, we have: a+blim sup(an+bn)a+b.a + b \leq \limsup (a_n + b_n) \leq a + b.

Thus, lim sup(an+bn)=a+b.\limsup (a_n + b_n) = a + b.

This completes the proof.


Would you like a more detailed breakdown of any part of the proof?

Here are some related questions for further exploration:

  1. What is the difference between lim\lim and lim sup\limsup?
  2. How do you find the lim sup\limsup of a sequence?
  3. What is the significance of a sequence being bounded?
  4. How does the value of liman=a>0\lim a_n = a > 0 affect the outcome of the problem?
  5. What are the properties of bounded sequences?
  6. Can the result still hold if liman=0\lim a_n = 0?
  7. How can we generalize this proof to complex sequences?
  8. What is the role of ϵ\epsilon in the proof?

Tip: When working with limits and lim sup\limsup, always keep the definitions and properties in mind. This will help ensure accuracy and clarity in proofs.