Math Problem Statement

Consider the following problem: you're given an unweighted graph G G, a source node u u, a destination node v v, and an "intermediate" node x x. Your goal is to find a shortest path from u u to v v that passes through x x.

Your friend proposes the following algorithm: run a BFS starting at node u u, then terminate it when it reaches node x x. Then start a BFS at node x x, and terminate it when it reaches node v v.

Does this algorithm work?

Choice 1 of 2:yes

Choice 2 of 2:no

Solution

The proposed algorithm does not work in general. Here's why:

The algorithm suggests running a Breadth-First Search (BFS) from the source node uu to the intermediate node xx, and then a separate BFS from node xx to the destination node vv. While BFS finds the shortest path in an unweighted graph, the problem arises from running the two BFS operations independently.

Explanation:

  1. First BFS (from uu to xx): This BFS will find the shortest path from uu to xx.
  2. Second BFS (from xx to vv): This BFS will find the shortest path from xx to vv.

However, the algorithm does not consider that the shortest path from uu to vv via xx may require you to take a different route from uu to xx than the one found in the first BFS. In other words, the shortest path from uu to vv via xx is not necessarily the concatenation of the shortest path from uu to xx and the shortest path from xx to vv.

Example Counterexample:

Consider the following graph:

  • uu connects directly to vv with a distance of 1.
  • uu connects to xx with a distance of 2.
  • xx connects to vv with a distance of 2.

If you use the proposed algorithm:

  1. The first BFS finds the shortest path from uu to xx as having a length of 2.
  2. The second BFS finds the shortest path from xx to vv as having a length of 2.

So, according to this algorithm, the path uuxxvv would have a total length of 4. However, the direct path uuvv has a length of 1, which is shorter than 4. Therefore, the algorithm fails to find the true shortest path that must pass through xx.

Conclusion:

The correct answer is no—the algorithm does not necessarily find the shortest path from uu to vv via xx.

Would you like to explore more on this topic or have any further questions? Here are some related questions:

  1. What is the correct algorithm to find the shortest path through an intermediate node?
  2. How does BFS work in an unweighted graph?
  3. Can Dijkstra's algorithm be used for the same problem in weighted graphs?
  4. What are the complexities of various shortest path algorithms?
  5. How does adding weights change the problem and solutions?

Tip: In graph problems, always consider whether intermediate steps in an algorithm might overlook some possibilities that could lead to better solutions.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Graph Theory
Shortest Path Problem
Breadth-First Search (BFS)
Algorithm Analysis

Formulas

-

Theorems

-

Suitable Grade Level

Advanced High School to College Level