Math Problem Statement
is this proof good? \begin{proposition} Let $X$ be a normed vector space. Prove that $|x|-|y| \leq|x-y|$. \end{proposition} \begin{proof} We prove the reverse triangle inequality. Start with
By the triangle inequality, which states that $|x+y| \leq |x| + |y|$, we have
Thus, $|x|-|y| \leq|x-y|$. \end{proof}
Solution
The proof you presented is almost correct but can be improved for clarity and rigor. Here's a detailed review:
Comments on the Proof:
-
Starting Step: You begin by writing: which is a valid identity. However, it's not necessary to express this way explicitly. You could directly apply the triangle inequality to .
-
Triangle Inequality Application: You correctly invoke the triangle inequality to conclude that: But more explanation is needed. It's better to explicitly state that this inequality follows directly from the definition of the triangle inequality: with and .
-
Subtraction: In the next step, you correctly subtract from both sides to get: This step is clear and valid.
Suggested Improvement:
You can slightly rephrase the argument to improve its clarity and flow. Here's a slightly revised version of your proof:
Revised Proof:
We aim to prove the reverse triangle inequality, which states that .
By the definition of a norm, we have: Applying the triangle inequality , with and , gives: Subtracting from both sides, we obtain: Thus, the reverse triangle inequality holds:
This completes the proof.
Summary:
- The logic of the proof is correct, but rephrasing some steps and explicitly mentioning the use of the triangle inequality enhances clarity.
- Make sure to state explicitly why each inequality follows from the definition of the triangle inequality.
Would you like more details on any part of the explanation?
Related Questions:
- Can you prove the strict reverse triangle inequality under certain conditions?
- How does this inequality behave in finite-dimensional normed spaces compared to infinite-dimensional ones?
- What other inequalities are consequences of the triangle inequality in normed vector spaces?
- How can we generalize the reverse triangle inequality to more general metric spaces?
- Does equality hold in the reverse triangle inequality for certain norms, like the Euclidean norm?
Tip: Always carefully identify where specific properties of the norm or space (such as the triangle inequality) are applied in your proofs for clarity.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Normed Vector Spaces
Inequalities
Formulas
Triangle Inequality: $\|a + b\| \leq \|a\| + \|b\|$
Theorems
Reverse Triangle Inequality
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate
Related Recommendation
Proof of Reverse Triangle Inequality in Normed Vector Spaces
Proof of ‖x + y‖² = ‖x‖² + ‖y‖² in Inner Product Spaces
Prove ||x| - |y|| ≤ |x - y| Without Using the Triangle Inequality
Proof of the Reverse Triangle Inequality Using the Triangle Inequality
Understanding the Inequality || A1 + e1 - A2 - e2 || <= ||A1-A2|| + ||e1|| + ||e2||