Math Problem Statement

prove that root 5 is not a rational using the "parity" argument:

let us start: assume that x^2 = 5 and x = m/n (m,n E N) then m^2/n^2 = 5, that is m^2 = 5n^2.

then m (and n) is either odd or even. there are four possible combinations. get a contradiction for each subcase

Solution

To prove that 5\sqrt{5} is irrational using a parity argument, we'll assume, for contradiction, that 5\sqrt{5} is rational. That is, assume:

x=mn,wherem,nNandgcd(m,n)=1x = \frac{m}{n}, \quad \text{where} \quad m, n \in \mathbb{N} \quad \text{and} \quad \gcd(m,n) = 1

This means mm and nn have no common factors other than 1. Also, x2=5x^2 = 5, so squaring both sides gives:

(mn)2=5    m2n2=5    m2=5n2\left(\frac{m}{n}\right)^2 = 5 \implies \frac{m^2}{n^2} = 5 \implies m^2 = 5n^2

Now, m2=5n2m^2 = 5n^2 implies that m2m^2 is divisible by 5. Thus, mm must also be divisible by 5 (since any square divisible by a prime implies the original number is divisible by that prime). So, we can write:

m=5kfor some integerkm = 5k \quad \text{for some integer} \quad k

Substitute this into the equation m2=5n2m^2 = 5n^2:

(5k)2=5n2    25k2=5n2    n2=5k2(5k)^2 = 5n^2 \implies 25k^2 = 5n^2 \implies n^2 = 5k^2

This shows that n2n^2 is also divisible by 5, which means nn must be divisible by 5.

Contradiction:

Now, both mm and nn are divisible by 5, which contradicts our assumption that gcd(m,n)=1\gcd(m,n) = 1 (since mm and nn would share a factor of 5). Therefore, our original assumption that 5\sqrt{5} is rational must be false.

Thus, 5\sqrt{5} is irrational.


Exploring the four cases (odd/even combinations):

  • Case 1: mm and nn are both even:
    If both mm and nn are even, then mn\frac{m}{n} is not in its lowest terms, contradicting the assumption that gcd(m,n)=1\gcd(m,n) = 1.

  • Case 2: mm is even, nn is odd:
    If mm is even, then m2m^2 is divisible by 4. However, since m2=5n2m^2 = 5n^2, m2m^2 must also be divisible by 5. This creates a contradiction, as no number can be divisible by both 4 and 5 unless it's divisible by 20, which would imply that both mm and nn are divisible by 5, contradicting our assumption.

  • Case 3: mm is odd, nn is even:
    If nn is even, n2n^2 is divisible by 4. But m2=5n2m^2 = 5n^2, so m2m^2 must be divisible by 20, which implies that mm must also be divisible by 5, again contradicting the assumption that mm and nn have no common factors.

  • Case 4: mm and nn are both odd:
    If both mm and nn are odd, then m2m^2 is odd and n2n^2 is odd. But m2=5n2m^2 = 5n^2 implies that m2m^2 is divisible by 5, so mm must be divisible by 5, leading to the same contradiction that mm and nn are not coprime.

In all cases, a contradiction arises, which proves that 5\sqrt{5} cannot be rational.

Would you like more details or have any further questions?


Here are five related questions:

  1. Can this method be extended to prove the irrationality of p\sqrt{p} for any prime pp?
  2. How does the method of infinite descent relate to the proof of irrationality?
  3. What are other common proofs used to show irrationality of square roots of primes?
  4. How can parity arguments be applied in number theory outside irrationality proofs?
  5. What is the generalization of this parity argument to higher roots (e.g., p3\sqrt[3]{p})?

Tip: Always check if an assumption leads to a contradiction in proofs involving rationality or coprimeness.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Number Theory
Irrational Numbers
Parity Argument
Prime Factorization

Formulas

x = m/n, where gcd(m,n) = 1
m^2 = 5n^2

Theorems

Irrationality of Square Roots
Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-12