Math Problem Statement

Consider a function f : A → B. Is it true that (a) For any X, Y ⊂ A we have f (X) ∩ f (Y ) = f (X ∩ Y )?

Solution

To determine whether the statement is true, let us carefully analyze the claim.

Problem Setup:

We are given a function f:ABf: A \to B and subsets X,YAX, Y \subseteq A. The claim is:

f(X)f(Y)=f(XY)f(X) \cap f(Y) = f(X \cap Y)

where:

  • f(X)f(X) represents the image of the subset XX, i.e., f(X)={f(x)xX}f(X) = \{f(x) \mid x \in X\}, and similarly for f(Y)f(Y).
  • XYX \cap Y is the intersection of subsets XX and YY.

Step 1: Analyze f(X)f(Y)f(X) \cap f(Y)

The intersection f(X)f(Y)f(X) \cap f(Y) contains all elements bBb \in B such that b=f(x1)b = f(x_1) for some x1Xx_1 \in X and b=f(x2)b = f(x_2) for some x2Yx_2 \in Y.

In other words: f(X)f(Y)={bBb=f(x) for some xXY or xX and xY}.f(X) \cap f(Y) = \{b \in B \mid b = f(x) \text{ for some } x \in X \cap Y \text{ or } x \in X \text{ and } x \in Y\}.

Step 2: Analyze f(XY)f(X \cap Y)

The image of XYX \cap Y is: f(XY)={f(x)xXY}.f(X \cap Y) = \{f(x) \mid x \in X \cap Y\}.

This directly represents the set of function values for elements that are in both XX and YY.

Step 3: Compare f(X)f(Y)f(X) \cap f(Y) and f(XY)f(X \cap Y)

  • Key Observation: It is possible that f(x1)=f(x2)f(x_1) = f(x_2) even though x1x2x_1 \neq x_2. This means that the function ff may not be injective (one-to-one). If ff is not injective, there may exist elements in f(X)f(Y)f(X) \cap f(Y) that do not correspond to any element in XYX \cap Y.

Example:

Let A={1,2}A = \{1, 2\}, B={a}B = \{a\}, and f(1)=f(2)=af(1) = f(2) = a. Take subsets X={1}X = \{1\}, Y={2}Y = \{2\}:

  • XY=X \cap Y = \emptyset, so f(XY)=f()=f(X \cap Y) = f(\emptyset) = \emptyset.
  • f(X)={a}f(X) = \{a\}, f(Y)={a}f(Y) = \{a\}, so f(X)f(Y)={a}f(X) \cap f(Y) = \{a\}.

Here, f(X)f(Y)f(XY)f(X) \cap f(Y) \neq f(X \cap Y).

Conclusion:

The statement is false in general. It only holds if ff is an injective (one-to-one) function, where f(x1)=f(x2)    x1=x2f(x_1) = f(x_2) \implies x_1 = x_2.


Do you want a more detailed explanation or additional examples?
Here are five related questions to consider:

  1. What are the conditions under which f(X)f(Y)=f(XY)f(X) \cap f(Y) = f(X \cap Y) is always true?
  2. How does the surjectivity or injectivity of a function affect operations on subsets?
  3. Can you provide an example where ff is surjective but the given statement fails?
  4. What happens if ff is a bijection? Does the equality always hold?
  5. How does the image of a function relate to other set operations like union or difference?

Tip: When comparing images of functions, always check whether the function is injective or surjective, as this determines many important properties.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Set Theory
Functions
Subset Operations
Image of a Function

Formulas

f(X) = {f(x) | x ∈ X}
f(X) ∩ f(Y) = {b ∈ B | b = f(x1) for x1 ∈ X and b = f(x2) for x2 ∈ Y}
f(X ∩ Y) = {f(x) | x ∈ X ∩ Y}

Theorems

Properties of Functions
Injectivity and Surjectivity

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate (Mathematics) or Advanced High School