Math Problem Statement
All are valid arguments. Construct a formal proof for each argument. Use a Statement/ Reason Table. g → ∼n (p ∨ q) → r r → w g ∨ p ——————— n → w
Solution
To construct a formal proof using a statement/reason table for the argument:
Given premises:
Conclusion:
Let's construct the proof in a structured format.
Statement/Reason Table
Step | Statement | Reason |
---|---|---|
1 | Premise | |
2 | Premise | |
3 | Premise | |
4 | Premise | |
5 | Assume | Assumption for Conditional Proof |
6 | Modus Tollens on Step 1 and 5 | |
7 | Disjunctive Syllogism on Step 4 and 6 | |
8 | Addition on Step 7 | |
9 | Modus Ponens on Step 2 and 8 | |
10 | Modus Ponens on Step 3 and 9 | |
11 | Conditional Proof from Steps 5–10 |
Explanation
In this proof, we assume to derive using the premises given. Here's how it unfolds:
- Steps 1–4 list the premises.
- Step 5 assumes for the purpose of a conditional proof.
- Step 6 uses and our assumption of to conclude (if were true, would not be true).
- Step 7 applies disjunctive syllogism to the statement , concluding .
- Step 8 uses addition to state , which lets us apply the implication to get in Step 9.
- Steps 10 and 11 conclude with from and complete the proof that .
This formal proof shows that is logically derived from the given premises.
Would you like further details or have any questions?
- How can we use conditional proofs to derive implications?
- What role does Modus Ponens play in deriving conclusions?
- How does Disjunctive Syllogism simplify complex arguments?
- What is the purpose of assuming a statement in a proof?
- Why is Addition important in formal logic proofs?
Tip: Conditional proofs often start with assuming the antecedent to derive the consequent, helping structure complex arguments logically.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Propositional Logic
Formal Proofs
Logical Reasoning
Formulas
Modus Ponens: If p → q and p, then q.
Modus Tollens: If p → q and ∼q, then ∼p.
Disjunctive Syllogism: If p ∨ q and ∼p, then q.
Addition: If p, then p ∨ q.
Theorems
Modus Ponens
Modus Tollens
Disjunctive Syllogism
Conditional Proof
Suitable Grade Level
College-level Logic or Advanced High School (Grades 11-12)