Math Problem Statement
Let a, b, and c be integers. Consider the following conditional statement: If a divides bc, then a divides b or a divides c. Determine whether the statement is true or false. Prove it if it is true or provide a counterexample if it is false
Solution
The given statement is:
If divides , then divides or divides .
To determine whether the statement is true or false, let's analyze it by considering a counterexample.
Analysis
The statement asserts that if , meaning that divides the product , then either or must be true. We need to check if this condition holds in all cases.
Counterexample:
Consider the integers , , and .
-
First, check if . We calculate: Since (because ), the condition is satisfied.
-
Now, check if or :
- For , we check if . This is false, because is not an integer.
- For , we check if . This is also false, because is not an integer.
Conclusion
In this case, we have (because ), but neither nor . This provides a counterexample showing that the statement is false.
Thus, the conditional statement "If divides , then divides or divides " is false.
Further Exploration
If you'd like, we can explore:
- Why the distributive property of divisibility does not always apply.
- Other counterexamples involving different integers.
- Related properties of divisibility and how they can be used in proofs.
- The logical structure of conditional statements and their negations.
- The role of prime factorization in divisibility problems.
Tip: When dealing with divisibility, always test edge cases or small numbers to identify potential counterexamples!
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Divisibility
Number Theory
Formulas
Divisibility condition a | bc
Counterexample method
Theorems
Properties of divisibility
Suitable Grade Level
Grades 9-12
Related Recommendation
Divisibility in Number Theory: If a Divides c and b Divides c, Does ab Divide c?
Proof: If c Divides b and b Divides a, Then c Divides a
Proof: If ac divides bc, then a divides b
Prove Divisibility: If a|b and a|c, then a|(bc) for Integers a, b, c
Proof Problem in Number Theory: Divisibility and Theorems