Math Problem Statement

Elizabeth has a choice between two equivalent investments. Option A: Invest $1,000 and receive $100 at the end of every two years forever. Option B: Invest $1,000 and receive $170 at the end of every three years forever. Define i_A as the effective annual interest rate for investment A and i_B as the effective annual interest rate for investment B. calculate i_A/i_B

Solution

We are given two investment options, and we need to find the ratio of the effective annual interest rates, iAiB\frac{i_A}{i_B}, for these investments.

Option A:

  • Invest $1,000 and receive $100 every 2 years forever.

This means the cash flow is $100 every 2 years, and we want to determine the effective annual interest rate iAi_A.

The present value of the perpetuity in Option A can be written as: PV=100(1+iA)2+100(1+iA)4+100(1+iA)6+PV = \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^2} + \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^4} + \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^6} + \dots This is a perpetuity with payments every 2 years. The present value formula for such a perpetuity with a payment of $100 every 2 years is: PV=100(1+iA)21PV = \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^2 - 1} Since the initial investment is $1,000, we equate this to the present value of the perpetuity: 1000=100(1+iA)211000 = \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^2 - 1}

Option B:

  • Invest $1,000 and receive $170 every 3 years forever.

Similarly, the present value of the perpetuity in Option B can be written as: PV=170(1+iB)3+170(1+iB)6+170(1+iB)9+PV = \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^3} + \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^6} + \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^9} + \dots The present value formula for this perpetuity is: PV=170(1+iB)31PV = \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^3 - 1} Again, the initial investment is $1,000, so we equate this to the present value: 1000=170(1+iB)311000 = \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^3 - 1}

Step 1: Solve for iAi_A

We now solve for iAi_A from the equation: 1000=100(1+iA)211000 = \frac{100}{(1+i_A)^2 - 1}

Step 2: Solve for iBi_B

We also solve for iBi_B from the equation: 1000=170(1+iB)311000 = \frac{170}{(1+i_B)^3 - 1}

Step 3: Calculate iAiB\frac{i_A}{i_B}

Let's solve these equations to find the effective interest rates and their ratio. I'll do that now.The solutions for the effective interest rates iAi_A and iBi_B are as follows:

  • iA=1+11010i_A = \frac{-1 + \sqrt{110}}{10}
  • iB=1+1170310i_B = \frac{-1 + \sqrt[3]{1170}}{10}

The ratio iAiB\frac{i_A}{i_B} is:

iAiB=1+1101+11703\frac{i_A}{i_B} = \frac{-1 + \sqrt{110}}{-1 + \sqrt[3]{1170}}

Let's compute the numerical value of this ratio next.The ratio of the effective annual interest rates iAiB\frac{i_A}{i_B} is approximately 0.908.

This means that the interest rate for investment A is about 90.8% of the interest rate for investment B.

Would you like any further clarification or additional details?

Here are 5 related questions to explore:

  1. How do perpetuities work in financial mathematics?
  2. What are the implications of choosing between different cash flow frequencies?
  3. How does the present value of a perpetuity depend on the interest rate?
  4. How can the effective annual interest rate be compared across different investments?
  5. What are other financial instruments that use similar perpetuity formulas?

Tip: When comparing investments, consider not only the interest rates but also the timing and frequency of cash flows, as these can affect the overall value over time.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Perpetuity
Present Value
Effective Annual Interest Rate

Formulas

Present Value of perpetuity: PV = C / (r - g)
Option A: 1000 = 100 / ((1 + i_A)^2 - 1)
Option B: 1000 = 170 / ((1 + i_B)^3 - 1)
Ratio of interest rates: i_A / i_B = (-1 + sqrt(110)) / (-1 + cbrt(1170))

Theorems

Perpetuity Formula
Effective Interest Rate Calculation

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Finance / Economics