Math Problem Statement
Two players play a game on a board with 1 row and 117 columns. They take turns making moves. On each turn, a player can delete either a single square or two consecutive squares. Player 1 makes the first move. The player that makes the last move wins. Determine if any player has a winning strategy, and if so, who it would be.
Solution
To determine which player has a winning strategy, we can analyze the game using game theory, specifically focusing on the concepts of winning and losing positions.
Key Concepts
- Winning Position: A position where a player can guarantee a win regardless of the opponent's moves.
- Losing Position: A position where any move leaves the opponent in a winning position.
The game starts with 117 squares. A player can:
- Remove 1 square.
- Remove 2 consecutive squares.
This creates smaller sub-games for the opponent.
Step-by-Step Analysis
Base Cases:
- : Only 1 square exists.
- The first player removes it and wins. This is a winning position.
- : Two squares exist.
- The first player removes both (taking 2 consecutive squares) and wins. This is a winning position.
- : Three squares exist.
- The first player can:
- Remove 1 square, leaving 2 squares (a winning position for the opponent).
- Remove 2 squares, leaving 1 square (a winning position for the opponent).
- Thus, is a losing position.
- The first player can:
Generalizing the Pattern:
From the base cases, observe:
- If the opponent is left with , they are in a losing position.
- Players aim to leave their opponent in a losing position.
Recursive Strategy:
- For , consider the current player’s moves:
- Remove 1 square: Leaves .
- Remove 2 squares: Leaves .
If either or is a losing position, the current position is a winning position.
Winning and Losing Positions:
Using the above logic, compute the sequence of positions:
- : Winning position.
- : Winning position.
- : Losing position.
- : Winning position (leave for the opponent).
- : Winning position (leave for the opponent).
- : Losing position (any move leaves or , both winning for the opponent).
- Continuing this pattern, (multiples of 3) are losing positions.
Starting Position ():
- is a multiple of 3 ().
- Thus, is a losing position.
Conclusion
- Player 1 starts in a losing position ().
- Player 2 has a winning strategy by always leaving a multiple of 3 for Player 1 after their turn.
Would you like a detailed explanation of the optimal moves for Player 2 or further questions on game theory concepts? Here are 5 related questions:
- How would the strategy change if the board had a different number of squares?
- What if players could remove 1, 2, or 3 consecutive squares?
- How can this concept be extended to boards with multiple rows?
- How are winning and losing positions related to the concept of "Nimbers" in combinatorial game theory?
- What algorithms can efficiently compute winning positions for larger games?
Tip: Understanding patterns in simple cases is key to solving combinatorial games.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Game Theory
Combinatorial Games
Winning and Losing Positions
Formulas
-
Theorems
Nim Game Strategy
Suitable Grade Level
Grades 9-12
Related Recommendation
Strategy Game on a 1x2019 Grid: Can the First Player Guarantee a Win?
Winning Strategy in Combinatorial Game: Adding the 18th Edge
Winning Strategy in a Combinatorial Game with Triangle and Interior Vertices
Winning Strategy for Alternating Disk Game Using Nim-Sum in Game Theory
Maximize Tokens on a 2020 x 2020 Board - Non-attacking Placement Strategy