Math Problem Statement

The rent on an apartment you like is $1350 per month. The monthly mortgage payment for a house you like would be $1600, of which approximately $1300 would go toward interest. Decide whether your monthly expense would be higher for the apartment or the house in the following cases. Assume you are single and assume the 2021 value of $12,550 for the standard deduction.

Solution

The problem presented is asking you to decide whether it is cheaper to rent or own a home, based on given tax and expense information. Here’s how we can approach solving part (a):

Known Information:

  1. Rent: $1350 per month.
  2. Mortgage: $1600 per month, of which $1300 goes toward interest.
  3. Tax bracket: 24%.
  4. Deductible expenses:
    • Charitable donations: $4300.
    • State and local taxes (SALT): $9000.
  5. Standard deduction: $12,550 (2021 value).

Approach:

  1. Deductions for owning the house:

    • Mortgage interest deduction: $1300 per month, or $15,600 annually.
    • Total deductions (charity, SALT, mortgage interest):
      15,600+4,300+9,000=28,90015,600 + 4,300 + 9,000 = 28,900
    • Compare this total deduction to the standard deduction of $12,550. Since $28,900 is higher, you would itemize deductions instead of taking the standard deduction.
  2. Tax Savings:

    • Tax savings from itemized deductions:
      28,900×24%=6,936 per year, or 578 per month.28,900 \times 24\% = 6,936 \text{ per year, or } 578 \text{ per month}.
    • After tax savings, the effective monthly mortgage payment is:
      1600578=1022.1600 - 578 = 1022.
  3. Comparison:

    • Renting costs $1350 per month.
    • Owning the house (after tax savings) costs $1022 per month.

Thus, it is cheaper to own the house, with a monthly expense of $1022.

Let me know if you'd like more details on any part of the calculation!

Follow-up questions:

  1. What are the tax implications of choosing to own vs rent in different tax brackets?
  2. How do changing interest rates affect this calculation?
  3. What would happen if the rent was higher than the current mortgage payment?
  4. What are the long-term financial benefits of owning a house vs renting?
  5. How would the calculation change if the deductible expenses increased?

Tip:

Always consider both short-term costs and long-term financial benefits when comparing renting and owning.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Tax deductions
Effective cost calculation
Comparison of monthly expenses

Formulas

Total Itemized Deductions = Mortgage Interest + Charitable Donations + SALT
Tax Savings = Total Itemized Deductions × Tax Bracket Percentage
Effective Monthly Mortgage = Monthly Mortgage Payment - Monthly Tax Savings

Theorems

Tax deduction benefits for homeowners vs renters

Suitable Grade Level

College/Advanced High School