Math Problem Statement
For any two real numbers, x and y, if x and y are both rational, then x + y is also rational. Which facts are assumed, and which facts are proven in a direct proof of the theorem?
Solution
The question asks about the theorem:
"For any two real numbers, and , if and are both rational, then is also rational."
The task is to identify which assumptions and proven facts match this theorem.
Let's break down the options:
-
Option A:
- Assumed: is rational and is rational.
- Proven: is rational.
- This matches the theorem exactly, where we assume that both and are rational, and we are proving that their sum is rational.
-
Option B:
- Assumed: is rational.
- Proven: is rational or is rational.
- This is not correct because the theorem is proving something about the sum of two rational numbers, not making assumptions about the sum first.
-
Option C:
- Assumed: is rational or is rational.
- Proven: is rational.
- This is incorrect because the theorem requires both and to be rational to guarantee their sum is rational.
-
Option D:
- Assumed: is irrational.
- Proven: is irrational and is irrational.
- This is not related to the theorem at all, as the theorem deals with sums of rational numbers, not irrational numbers.
Correct Answer: A
Would you like more details on the reasoning? Here are some related questions:
- What defines a rational number mathematically?
- Can the sum of a rational number and an irrational number ever be rational?
- What is the difference between a direct and an indirect proof?
- How can you prove that the sum of two rational numbers is always rational?
- Why is option B an incorrect assumption about the sum of rational numbers?
Tip: When proving properties of numbers, always check the definitions (like rational or irrational) and see if they hold under operations such as addition or multiplication.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Rational Numbers
Real Numbers
Addition of Rational Numbers
Formulas
-
Theorems
Closure of Addition for Rational Numbers
Suitable Grade Level
High School