Math Problem Statement

For each of the following statements, if the statement is true then prove it, if the statement is false, then provide a counterexample. (a, b, c ∈ Z) (a) If a | b and c | d then ab | cd (b) If a | bc then a | b or a | c. (c) if a and b are positive and a2 | b2 then a | b

Solution

Let's address each of the statements one by one:


(a) If aba \mid b and cdc \mid d, then abcdab \mid cd.

Analysis:

  • aba \mid b means b=kab = ka for some integer kk.
  • cdc \mid d means d=lcd = lc for some integer ll.

Thus, we know:

  • b=kab = ka
  • d=lcd = lc

Now consider the product cdcd: cd=(ka)(lc)=kl(ac)cd = (ka)(lc) = kl(ac) This shows that cdcd is a multiple of abab, because cd=(kl)(ab)cd = (kl)(ab).

Hence, abcdab \mid cd.

Conclusion:

The statement is true.


(b) If abca \mid bc, then aba \mid b or aca \mid c.

Analysis:

This statement suggests that if aa divides the product bcbc, then aa must divide either bb or cc.

This is false, and a counterexample will demonstrate this.

Counterexample:

Let a=6a = 6, b=2b = 2, and c=3c = 3.

  • bc=2×3=6bc = 2 \times 3 = 6.
  • Clearly, abca \mid bc, because 666 \mid 6.

However:

  • a=6a = 6 does not divide b=2b = 2 (since 66 does not divide 22).
  • a=6a = 6 does not divide c=3c = 3 (since 66 does not divide 33).

Thus, abca \mid bc, but neither aba \mid b nor aca \mid c.

Conclusion:

The statement is false, as shown by the counterexample.


(c) If aa and bb are positive and a2b2a^2 \mid b^2, then aba \mid b.

Analysis:

The statement suggests that if a2a^2 divides b2b^2, then aa must divide bb.

Let’s analyze this. If a2b2a^2 \mid b^2, then there exists an integer kk such that: b2=ka2b^2 = k \cdot a^2 This implies: b=akb = a \cdot \sqrt{k} For bb to be an integer, kk must be a perfect square. Let k=m2k = m^2, so: b=amb = a \cdot m Thus, aba \mid b.

Conclusion:

The statement is true.


Final Summary:

  • (a) True. Proven.
  • (b) False. Counterexample provided.
  • (c) True. Proven.

Do you want more details or have any questions? Here are some related questions:

  1. Can you provide other counterexamples for statement (b)?
  2. What happens if one of aa, bb, or cc is negative?
  3. How would the statements change if aa, bb, or cc were not integers?
  4. Can you provide examples where a2b2a^2 \mid b^2 but the quotient b/ab/a is not 1?
  5. What would happen if a=0a = 0 in statement (a)?

Tip: When working with divisibility, always keep in mind how multiplication and factorization behave in relation to prime factorizations.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Number Theory
Divisibility
Counterexamples
Integer Properties

Formulas

a | b means b = ka for some integer k
c | d means d = lc for some integer l
If a^2 | b^2, then there exists k such that b = a√k

Theorems

Divisibility Rules
Properties of Multiples
Counterexample Proof

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate/Advanced High School