Math Problem Statement
For each of the following statements, if the statement is true then prove it, if the statement is false, then provide a counterexample. (a, b, c ∈ Z) (a) If a | b and c | d then ab | cd (b) If a | bc then a | b or a | c. (c) if a and b are positive and a2 | b2 then a | b
Solution
Let's address each of the statements one by one:
(a) If and , then .
Analysis:
- means for some integer .
- means for some integer .
Thus, we know:
Now consider the product : This shows that is a multiple of , because .
Hence, .
Conclusion:
The statement is true.
(b) If , then or .
Analysis:
This statement suggests that if divides the product , then must divide either or .
This is false, and a counterexample will demonstrate this.
Counterexample:
Let , , and .
- .
- Clearly, , because .
However:
- does not divide (since does not divide ).
- does not divide (since does not divide ).
Thus, , but neither nor .
Conclusion:
The statement is false, as shown by the counterexample.
(c) If and are positive and , then .
Analysis:
The statement suggests that if divides , then must divide .
Let’s analyze this. If , then there exists an integer such that: This implies: For to be an integer, must be a perfect square. Let , so: Thus, .
Conclusion:
The statement is true.
Final Summary:
- (a) True. Proven.
- (b) False. Counterexample provided.
- (c) True. Proven.
Do you want more details or have any questions? Here are some related questions:
- Can you provide other counterexamples for statement (b)?
- What happens if one of , , or is negative?
- How would the statements change if , , or were not integers?
- Can you provide examples where but the quotient is not 1?
- What would happen if in statement (a)?
Tip: When working with divisibility, always keep in mind how multiplication and factorization behave in relation to prime factorizations.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Number Theory
Divisibility
Counterexamples
Integer Properties
Formulas
a | b means b = ka for some integer k
c | d means d = lc for some integer l
If a^2 | b^2, then there exists k such that b = a√k
Theorems
Divisibility Rules
Properties of Multiples
Counterexample Proof
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate/Advanced High School
Related Recommendation
Proof of Divisibility Conditions: n^2 - 1 Modulo 8 and 3
Prove that n[(n^2) + 2] is a multiple of 3 using modulo arithmetic
Disproving a Mathematical Statement: Number Divisibility and Oddness
Prove by Contrapositive: Modular Arithmetic and Divisibility
True Statement Among Properties of Divisibility and Integers