Math Problem Statement

Part 3: Now perform some algebra to complete the proof as follows: - Multiply both sides of Proportion 1 by ac. Write the resulting equation. - Multiply both sides of Proportion 2 by bc. Write the resulting equation. - Add the two resulting equations and factor the right side of the equation. - Finally, use the fact that e + d = ___ by the Segment Addition Postulate to rewrite the equation. Error Analysis: A student used the figure in Part 2 of the example and wrote the following incorrect proof of the Pythagorean Theorem. Critique the student's proof.

Solution

Let's solve the problem step by step based on the content provided in the image.


Part 3 — Algebra to Complete the Proof:

  1. Step 1:
    Multiply both sides of Proportion 1 by acac.

    • Proportion 1 is likely ea=fc\frac{e}{a} = \frac{f}{c}.
    • Multiplying both sides by acac:
      ec=fae \cdot c = f \cdot a
  2. Step 2:
    Multiply both sides of Proportion 2 by bcbc.

    • Proportion 2 is likely db=fc\frac{d}{b} = \frac{f}{c}.
    • Multiplying both sides by bcbc:
      dc=fbd \cdot c = f \cdot b
  3. Step 3:
    Add the two resulting equations:
    ec+dc=fa+fbe \cdot c + d \cdot c = f \cdot a + f \cdot b
    Factoring the right-hand side:
    c(e+d)=f(a+b)c(e + d) = f(a + b)

  4. Step 4:
    Use the Segment Addition Postulate, which states that e+d=ce + d = c.
    Therefore, the equation becomes:
    c2=f2c^2 = f^2


Problem 11 — Error Analysis (Critique of the Student's Proof):

The student's proof has an error because they incorrectly assumed the Segment Addition Postulate can be applied in a way that leads to factoring errors.

The critical error is in their substitution and factoring step:

  • Incorrect Factoring:
    The student claimed:
    e2+2ed+d2=(e+d)2e^2 + 2ed + d^2 = (e + d)^2
    This is correct, but their logic in reaching that step from adding areas of triangles seems faulty.

Correct Critique: The similarity properties used and their application of the Segment Addition Postulate are not properly justified.


Do you want a detailed breakdown of why the student’s proof is incorrect? Let me know if you want further clarifications.


Relative Questions for Practice:

  1. How do you prove the Pythagorean Theorem using triangle similarity?
  2. What is the Segment Addition Postulate, and how is it applied in geometric proofs?
  3. How can you identify errors in algebraic proofs involving geometric properties?
  4. What are the key properties of similar triangles that are used in proofs?
  5. How do you correctly factor algebraic expressions to simplify equations in proofs?

Tip: Always double-check that every step in a proof is mathematically justified, especially when using geometric postulates or similarity rules.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Algebra
Geometric Proofs
Triangle Similarity

Formulas

Proportions in similar triangles (e/a = f/c, d/b = f/c)
Segment Addition Postulate: e + d = c
Pythagorean Theorem: a^2 + b^2 = c^2

Theorems

Pythagorean Theorem
Triangle Similarity Theorem
Segment Addition Postulate

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-11