Math Problem Statement
The primes $3$, $5$, and $17$ have the property that all of their quadratic nonresidues are also primitive roots. Find the next two primes with this property.
Solution
The problem involves finding the next two prime numbers such that all quadratic nonresidues modulo are also primitive roots modulo . We are given that the primes , , and have this property.
Understanding the Problem:
- Quadratic Residue: An integer is a quadratic residue modulo if there exists an integer such that . Otherwise, is a quadratic nonresidue modulo .
- Primitive Root: An integer is a primitive root modulo if the order of modulo is . That is, the powers modulo produce all the nonzero residues modulo .
Given Primes:
- For , the quadratic nonresidue is , and it is also a primitive root.
- For , the quadratic nonresidues are and , both of which are primitive roots.
- For , the quadratic nonresidues are , and all of these are primitive roots.
Approach:
We need to find the next two primes such that all quadratic nonresidues modulo are primitive roots modulo .
Steps:
-
Identify Quadratic Residues and Nonresidues:
- For each prime , list the quadratic residues and the nonresidues.
- Check if every quadratic nonresidue is a primitive root modulo .
-
Calculate the Primitive Roots:
- For each candidate prime , calculate the order of each quadratic nonresidue modulo .
-
Verification:
- Verify that all quadratic nonresidues are indeed primitive roots for the smallest primes.
Let's check the primes one by one:
Prime :
- Quadratic residues:
- Quadratic nonresidues:
- Primitive roots modulo 7: and .
However, is not a primitive root because . So, 7 does not satisfy the condition.
Prime :
- Quadratic residues:
- Quadratic nonresidues:
- Checking:
- , , , , , , , , , is a primitive root.
- Similarly, check for . (All are primitive roots.)
- Conclusion: is a valid prime.
Prime :
- Quadratic residues:
- Quadratic nonresidues:
- Checking:
- All these quadratic nonresidues are primitive roots modulo 13.
- Conclusion: is a valid prime.
Answer:
The next two primes with the property that all quadratic nonresidues are also primitive roots are and .
Would you like to dive deeper into any step, or explore related topics?
Related Questions:
- How do you find quadratic residues for a given prime ?
- What is the significance of a primitive root in number theory?
- Could there be a prime with exactly one quadratic nonresidue that is not a primitive root?
- How do these concepts relate to cryptography?
- What algorithms can efficiently determine primitive roots for large primes?
Tip: When analyzing properties of quadratic residues and nonresidues, modular arithmetic techniques and order determination are key tools in number theory.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Number Theory
Quadratic Residues
Primitive Roots
Modular Arithmetic
Formulas
x^2 ≡ a (mod p)
g^k ≡ 1 (mod p) where g is a primitive root and k = p-1
Theorems
Quadratic Residue Theorem
Primitive Root Theorem
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate