Math Problem Statement

Let the relation R(A,B,C,D,E,G,H) be the set of FDs: F = {AB→C, B→D, CD→E, CE→GH, G→A}. ● Are the following FDs correct : AB → E ? BG → C ? AB → G ? Justify your answers. ● What are the candidate keys of F?ansewer corecy

Solution

Part 1: Validating Functional Dependencies (FDs)

We will check if the following FDs hold in F={ABC,BD,CDE,CEGH,GA}F = \{ AB \to C, B \to D, CD \to E, CE \to GH, G \to A \}:

  1. ABEAB \to E:
    To verify, we check if ABAB can derive EE.

    • From ABCAB \to C, ABAB determines CC.
    • From CDECD \to E, we need DD and CC to determine EE.
    • DD can be obtained using BDB \to D. Hence, ABCAB \to C, BDB \to D, and CDECD \to E together imply ABEAB \to E.
      Conclusion: ABEAB \to E is correct.
  2. BGCBG \to C:
    To verify, we check if BGBG can determine CC.

    • ABCAB \to C tells us ABAB determines CC, but BGBG does not give access to ABAB.
    • GAG \to A means GG determines AA, so BGBG could be expanded to ABGABG. However, since BB and GG together don't directly lead to ABAB, we cannot derive CC.
      Conclusion: BGCBG \to C is incorrect.
  3. ABGAB \to G:
    To verify, we check if ABAB determines GG.

    • From the given FDs, ABCAB \to C, and CC is needed for CEGHCE \to GH.
    • However, ABGAB \to G is not directly derivable as ABAB does not guarantee EE, which is required to derive GG.
      Conclusion: ABGAB \to G is incorrect.

Part 2: Candidate Keys of FF

To determine the candidate keys, we need to identify the minimal set(s) of attributes that can determine all attributes in R(A,B,C,D,E,G,H)R(A, B, C, D, E, G, H).

Step 1: Determine the closure of attributes.

Start by finding what each attribute (or set of attributes) can determine using the given FDs:

  • ABAB:
    ABCAB \to C. From CC, CDECD \to E. From EE, CEGHCE \to GH. From GG, GAG \to A. Thus, AB{A,B,C,D,E,G,H}AB \to \{A, B, C, D, E, G, H\}.

  • BB:
    BDB \to D. No further attributes can be derived from BB alone.

  • GG:
    GAG \to A. With AA, no further attributes can be derived from GG.

Step 2: Identify candidate keys.

A candidate key must:

  1. Determine all attributes in RR.
  2. Be minimal (no proper subset should be a candidate key).
  • ABAB: From above, AB+={A,B,C,D,E,G,H}AB^+ = \{A, B, C, D, E, G, H\}. Thus, ABAB is a candidate key.
  • No proper subset of ABAB (e.g., AA, BB) determines all attributes.

Step 3: Verify alternative combinations.

Testing other combinations (e.g., BGBG, AGAG, etc.), none of them cover all attributes without requiring ABAB.

Conclusion: The only candidate key is ABAB.


Final Answers:

  1. Are the FDs correct?

    • ABEAB \to E: Correct.
    • BGCBG \to C: Incorrect.
    • ABGAB \to G: Incorrect.
  2. Candidate Key(s):
    The only candidate key is ABAB.


Do you want details or have questions? Here are some related questions:

  1. How is the closure of attributes determined?
  2. Can there be more than one candidate key in a relation?
  3. What is the role of minimality in candidate key selection?
  4. How do transitive dependencies affect FDs?
  5. Why are candidate keys important in normalization?

Tip: Always compute attribute closures systematically to avoid missing dependencies when determining keys or validating FDs.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Relational Database Theory
Functional Dependencies
Candidate Keys
Attribute Closure

Formulas

Attribute Closure
FD Validity
Minimal Superkeys

Theorems

Armstrong's Axioms
Candidate Key Definition

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate (Computer Science/Information Systems)