Math Problem Statement

Which of the statements in the choices are useful in proving or disproving the following statement? For integers π‘Ž, 𝑏, 𝑐, and 𝑑, a <>0, 𝑏 <> 0, if π‘Ž|𝑐 and 𝑏|𝑑, then π‘Žπ‘|𝑐𝑑.

Not enough information to answer the question. If b|d, b=md for some integer m If a|c, c=ka for some integer k If b|d, d=mb for some integer m If a|c and b|d, bd = (k1c)(k2d) for some integers k1 and k2 integer k If a|c, a=k*c for some integer k The statement is false for a=2 and c=3.

Solution

Let's analyze the statement carefully:

"For integers a,b,c,da, b, c, d with aβ‰ 0a \neq 0, bβ‰ 0b \neq 0, if a∣ca \mid c and b∣db \mid d, then ab∣cdab \mid cd."

We want to determine which of the provided statements are useful for proving or disproving this statement.

Step-by-Step Breakdown:

  1. a∣ca \mid c means c=k1β‹…ac = k_1 \cdot a for some integer k1k_1.

    • This simply means cc is divisible by aa.
  2. b∣db \mid d means d=mβ‹…bd = m \cdot b for some integer mm.

    • This indicates that dd is divisible by bb.
  3. Now consider the expression ab∣cdab \mid cd:

    • We want to see if the product abab divides the product cdcd. Using the fact that c=k1β‹…ac = k_1 \cdot a and d=mβ‹…bd = m \cdot b, we can substitute into cdcd: cd=(k1β‹…a)β‹…(mβ‹…b)=k1mβ‹…abcd = (k_1 \cdot a) \cdot (m \cdot b) = k_1 m \cdot ab
    • So, cd=k1mβ‹…abcd = k_1 m \cdot ab, which is clearly divisible by abab because the factor k1mk_1 m is just some integer.

Thus, the statement appears true, meaning ab∣cdab \mid cd is indeed valid.

Evaluating the given options:

  1. "If b∣db \mid d, then b=mβ‹…db = m \cdot d for some integer mm."

    • This statement is false. If b∣db \mid d, we should have d=mβ‹…bd = m \cdot b, not the other way around. This would not be directly helpful in proving the statement.
  2. "If a∣ca \mid c, then c=kβ‹…ac = k \cdot a for some integer kk."

    • This is true and useful. It directly follows the definition of divisibility and is required in the proof to express cc in terms of aa.
  3. "If b∣db \mid d, then d=mβ‹…bd = m \cdot b for some integer mm."

    • This is true and useful. This follows the definition of divisibility and is necessary for expressing dd in terms of bb.
  4. "If a∣ca \mid c and b∣db \mid d, then cd=(k1β‹…c)β‹…(k2β‹…d)cd = (k_1 \cdot c) \cdot (k_2 \cdot d) for some integers k1k_1 and k2k_2."

    • This is not correct. The correct way to express cdcd using divisibility is cd=k1mβ‹…abcd = k_1 m \cdot ab, not the product of cc and dd themselves.
  5. "If a∣ca \mid c, then a=kβ‹…ca = k \cdot c for some integer kk."

    • This is incorrect. If a∣ca \mid c, it should be c=kβ‹…ac = k \cdot a, not the other way around. This would not be useful.
  6. "The statement is false for a=2a = 2 and c=3c = 3."

    • This is incorrect. The statement holds true for a=2a = 2 and c=3c = 3, as long as the other divisibility conditions hold. Therefore, this statement is misleading and not useful for proving or disproving the original statement.

Conclusion:

The useful statements for proving the original statement are:

  • "If a∣ca \mid c, then c=kβ‹…ac = k \cdot a for some integer kk."
  • "If b∣db \mid d, then d=mβ‹…bd = m \cdot b for some integer mm."

Would you like to explore further details or have any specific questions?

Here are some related questions:

  1. How can divisibility properties be used to prove the general case for any integers a,b,c,da, b, c, d?
  2. What are some counterexamples for divisibility theorems?
  3. Can we prove this kind of divisibility for other algebraic structures beyond integers?
  4. How does this apply to prime numbers?
  5. What role does the greatest common divisor play in divisibility?

Tip: Always double-check the order of factors in divisibility. It's important to note that divisibility is typically defined with the divisor on the right side.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Divisibility
Algebra
Integer Properties

Formulas

If a|c, then c = k * a for some integer k
If b|d, then d = m * b for some integer m

Theorems

Divisibility Property
Basic Divisibility Theorem

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 10-12