Math Problem Statement

Prove the following by contraposition:

If a product of two positive real numbers is greater than 100, then at least one of the numbers is greater than 10.

Solution

To prove the statement by contraposition, we first need to recall what contraposition means. The contrapositive of an implication of the form:

P    QP \implies Q

is:

¬Q    ¬P\neg Q \implies \neg P

where:

  • PP is the hypothesis (the condition),
  • QQ is the conclusion.

So, the original statement is:

If the product of two positive real numbers is greater than 100, then at least one of the numbers is greater than 10.

In symbolic form, let aa and bb be the two positive real numbers. The original statement is:

(ab>100)    (a>10 or b>10)(a \cdot b > 100) \implies (a > 10 \text{ or } b > 10)

Step 1: Contrapositive of the Statement

To prove the statement by contraposition, we need to prove the contrapositive, which is:

¬(a>10 or b>10)    ¬(ab>100)\neg (a > 10 \text{ or } b > 10) \implies \neg (a \cdot b > 100)

Step 1.1: Simplifying the Contrapositive

The contrapositive involves negating the statement on both sides:

  1. Negating (a>10 or b>10)(a > 10 \text{ or } b > 10) gives us: ¬(a>10 or b>10)(a10 and b10)\neg (a > 10 \text{ or } b > 10) \equiv (a \leq 10 \text{ and } b \leq 10) This is because the negation of "or" becomes "and," and we must have both a10a \leq 10 and b10b \leq 10.

  2. Negating (ab>100)(a \cdot b > 100) gives us: ¬(ab>100)(ab100)\neg (a \cdot b > 100) \equiv (a \cdot b \leq 100)

Thus, the contrapositive is:

(a10 and b10)    (ab100)(a \leq 10 \text{ and } b \leq 10) \implies (a \cdot b \leq 100)

Step 2: Proving the Contrapositive

Now, we need to prove the contrapositive statement: If both a10a \leq 10 and b10b \leq 10, then ab100a \cdot b \leq 100.

If a10a \leq 10 and b10b \leq 10, the product aba \cdot b is maximized when both aa and bb are equal to 10. So:

ab1010=100a \cdot b \leq 10 \cdot 10 = 100

Thus, if both a10a \leq 10 and b10b \leq 10, it follows that ab100a \cdot b \leq 100, which proves the contrapositive.

Conclusion

Since we've proved the contrapositive of the original statement, we have thereby proven the original statement as well:

If the product of two positive real numbers is greater than 100, then at least one of the numbers is greater than 10.


Would you like further clarification or details on any of the steps? Here are some related questions to deepen your understanding:

  1. How can the contrapositive approach be useful in other types of proofs?
  2. What would happen if we used a different method to prove the statement (like direct proof)?
  3. Can the contrapositive method be applied to statements involving inequalities like a2>25    a>5a^2 > 25 \implies a > 5?
  4. How do logical equivalences like De Morgan’s laws play a role in contraposition proofs?
  5. What happens if one of the numbers aa or bb is negative or zero in this case?

Tip: When proving by contraposition, always ensure you correctly negate the "or" and "and" statements, as De Morgan's laws will guide you through this transformation.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Logic and Proofs
Inequalities
Contrapositive Proof

Formulas

Negation of logical statements (De Morgan's laws)
Product of two numbers: a * b

Theorems

Contrapositive equivalence in logic

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-12