Math Problem Statement
We have X gaussian (0, sigma x²), Z gaussian (0, sigma z²) indep of X and Y = X + Z. How can we naturally make the cov term appear in the expression E(X|Y), using for example X = Y - Z?
Solution
To derive the conditional expectation using the given expressions and introduce the covariance term naturally, follow these steps:
Step 1: Express Y in terms of X and Z
We have: where , , and they are independent, so .
Step 2: Formulate the conditional expectation
Since and are Gaussian random variables and is a linear combination of them, the conditional expectation is linear in . Thus: where and are constants to be determined.
Step 3: Compute using properties of joint distributions
- The joint distribution of is bivariate normal because and are Gaussian.
- The covariance matrix of is: \sigma_X^2 & \sigma_X^2 \\ \sigma_X^2 & \sigma_X^2 + \sigma_Z^2 \end{pmatrix}.$$
- The conditional expectation of given for a bivariate normal distribution is:
Step 4: Substitute the relation
Since , using this expression directly:
Because is independent of , the conditional expectation depends on its correlation with . Specifically:
Substituting this into the expression for :
Step 5: Covariance interpretation
The term appears in the formula for : so: where:
Conclusion
By using , the covariance term arises naturally in the conditional expectation. The expression:
demonstrates the dependency of on weighted by the relative variances (covariances) of the components.
Do you have any questions or would you like further clarifications?
Here are five related questions and one tip for further exploration:
- How can we generalize this method to non-Gaussian distributions?
- Why is the conditional expectation linear for jointly Gaussian variables?
- How does simplify given the independence of and ?
- How can we derive explicitly if the variances are unknown?
- What would happen if had a different mean, say ?
Tip: Always verify independence assumptions when computing conditional expectations involving sums of random variables.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Conditional Expectation
Gaussian Distributions
Covariance
Bivariate Normal Distribution
Formulas
Y = X + Z
E(X|Y) = aY + b
E(X|Y) = (Cov(X, Y) / Var(Y)) Y
E(X|Y) = Y - E(Z|Y)
E(Z|Y) = (sigma_Z^2 / (sigma_X^2 + sigma_Z^2)) Y
Theorems
Conditional Expectation for Bivariate Normal Distribution
Suitable Grade Level
Graduate-level mathematics
Related Recommendation
Covariance of X and Y where Y = e^X, X ~ N(0,1)
Conditional Expectation and Integrals Involving Odd Functions
Proving Uncorrelation Between Y2 and σ(X)-Measurable Random Variables
Calculate the Expectation of Conditional Probability P[X | (X+Y)]
Verify Partial-Averaging Property of Conditional Expectation and Compute E[Y|X] and E[Z|X]