Math Problem Statement

Charles uses a graphing calculator to find a quadratic regression model f for a given set of data. When he compares model f to an earlier regression model g for the same data, he determines that g more accurately models the data. Select all the statements that are true. A. Function f likely had fewer residuals near the x-axis than function g. B. Function f likely had more residuals equal to 0 than function g. C. Function g had more residuals near the y-axis than function f. D. Function g likely had a R2 value closer to 1 than function f. E. Function g likely had all positive residual values.

Solution

Let's go through each statement carefully based on the context that function ff is a quadratic regression model, and function gg is another regression model (possibly linear or quadratic) that more accurately models the data.

A. Function f likely had fewer residuals near the x-axis than function g.

  • False. The residuals of a regression model represent the differences between the observed data points and the model's predicted values. If function ff is less accurate than gg, we would expect that the residuals for ff would be larger or more scattered. This doesn't necessarily mean there would be fewer residuals near the x-axis (where residual = 0), just that the model ff would likely have more dispersed residuals.

B. Function f likely had more residuals equal to 0 than function g.

  • False. The residuals being equal to 0 would imply that the model perfectly predicts those points. Since model gg is described as more accurate, it's more likely that gg would have more residuals close to 0 than ff.

C. Function g had more residuals near the y-axis than function f.

  • False. Residuals near the y-axis correspond to predictions where the independent variable xx is near 0. The accuracy of a model doesn't necessarily have to do with the proximity of residuals to the y-axis, but rather how closely the model's predictions match the observed values across all points. Since gg is more accurate, it should generally have smaller residuals overall, not necessarily more near the y-axis.

D. Function g likely had an R2R^2 value closer to 1 than function f.

  • True. The R2R^2 value indicates the proportion of the variance in the data that is explained by the model. A more accurate model typically has an R2R^2 value closer to 1. Since gg is said to more accurately model the data, it likely has a higher R2R^2 than ff.

E. Function g likely had all positive residual values.

  • False. Residuals can be both positive and negative depending on whether the model overestimates or underestimates the data at any point. It's unlikely that all residuals for gg would be positive because residuals usually vary in sign across different data points.

Conclusion:

The only true statement is:

  • D. Function g likely had an R2R^2 value closer to 1 than function f.

Further Questions:

  1. How does the value of R2R^2 relate to the accuracy of a regression model?
  2. What is the difference between residuals and errors in regression analysis?
  3. Why might a quadratic regression model not always provide a better fit than other types of regression models?
  4. How does the residual plot help in evaluating the fit of a regression model?
  5. What factors can cause a regression model to have a lower R2R^2 value?

Tip:

When comparing regression models, it’s helpful to look at both the R2R^2 value and the residual plot. A higher R2R^2 typically indicates a better fit, but the residual plot can reveal patterns that suggest if the model is missing a key aspect of the data.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Regression Analysis
Residuals
R-squared (R²)
Quadratic Regression

Formulas

R² = 1 - (Sum of Squared Residuals / Total Sum of Squares)

Theorems

Least Squares Regression
Coefficient of Determination (R²)

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-12