Math Problem Statement

: Consider an arbitrary x∈{1,2}x∈{1,2}, and let us consider the number of ways for xx to be in some of the sets so that the constraints are satisfied. We divide into a few cases: - Case: x∉A1x∈/A1​. Then xx cannot be in any of the sets. So there is one possibility. - Case: x∈A1xA1​ but x∉A2x∈/A2​. Then the only other sets that xx could be in are A3,A5,A7A3​,A5​,A7​, and xx could be in some collection of them. There are 8 possibilities in this case. - Case: x∈A2xA2​. Then x∈A1xA1​ automatically. There are 4 independent choices to be make here: (1) whether x∈A5;(2)xA5​;(2) whether x∈A7;(3)xA7​;(3) whether x∈A3xA3​, and if yes, whether x∈A6xA6​; (4) whether x∈A4xA4​, and if yes, whether x∈A8xA8​. There are 2×2×3×3=362×2×3×3=36 choices here. Therefore, there are 1+8+36=451+8+36=45 ways to place xx into some of the sets. Since the choices for x=1x=1 and x=2x=2 are made independently, we see that the total number of possibilities is 452=2025452=2025.

Solution

The problem involves determining the number of ways that an element x{1,2}x \in \{1, 2\} can be placed in various sets while satisfying certain constraints. The process is broken down into three cases, each of which represents a different situation that constrains the number of ways xx can be placed in these sets. Let's go through the steps carefully.

Case 1: xA1x \notin A_1 and xA1x^* \notin A_1

  • If xA1x \notin A_1 and xA1x^* \notin A_1, then xxx x^* cannot be in any of the sets.
  • Number of possibilities: 1 way (the only possibility is to not include xxx x^* in any sets).

Case 2: xA1x \in A_1 and xA1x^* \in A_1 but xA2x \notin A_2 and xA2x^* \notin A_2

  • Here, xxx x^* could be placed in sets A3,A5,A7A_3, A_5, A_7. Since xA2x \notin A_2 and xA2x^* \notin A_2, we are only concerned with choices for A3,A5,A7A_3, A_5, A_7.
  • For each of these three sets, there are two options: either xxx x^* is in the set, or it is not.
  • Number of possibilities: 23=82^3 = 8 ways.

Case 3: xA2x \in A_2 and xA2x^* \in A_2

  • If xA2x \in A_2 and xA2x^* \in A_2, then xA1x \in A_1 and xA1x^* \in A_1 automatically. Now, we need to consider a set of independent choices for placing xxx x^* into additional sets:

    1. Whether xA5x \in A_5 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    2. Whether xA5x^* \in A_5 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    3. Whether xA7x \in A_7 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    4. Whether xA7x^* \in A_7 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    5. Whether xA3x \in A_3 (3 choices: Yes, No, or with an additional condition xA6x \in A_6).
    6. Whether xA3x^* \in A_3 (3 choices: Yes, No, or with an additional condition xA6x^* \in A_6).
    7. Whether xA4x \in A_4 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    8. Whether xA4x^* \in A_4 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    9. Whether xA8x \in A_8 (2 choices: Yes or No).
    10. Whether xA8x^* \in A_8 (2 choices: Yes or No).
  • There are 36 independent choices, calculated as 2×2×3×3=362 \times 2 \times 3 \times 3 = 36.

Total Number of Possibilities for One xxx x^*:

  • Adding up the possibilities from all the cases: 1+8+36=451 + 8 + 36 = 45 Thus, for one specific xxx x^*, there are 45 ways to place it in the sets.

Considering Both x=1x = 1 and x=2x = 2:

  • Since the choices for x=1x = 1 and x=2x = 2 are independent, we multiply the total number of possibilities for each: 45×45=202545 \times 45 = 2025 Thus, the total number of ways to place xxx x^* into the sets for both x=1x = 1 and x=2x = 2 is 2025.

Would you like further clarification on any of the cases or steps involved? Also, here are a few questions to extend the understanding:

  1. How would the number of possibilities change if there were more sets involved in the conditions?
  2. How would this problem change if xx could belong to more than just the two sets A1A_1 and A2A_2?
  3. Can you think of a way to generalize this problem for any number of elements x{1,2,3,...,n}x \in \{1, 2, 3, ..., n\}?
  4. How would the solution change if there were additional dependencies between the sets, such as restrictions where xx in one set implies that xx^* must also be in another set?
  5. What if the sets A3,A5,A7A_3, A_5, A_7 had different numbers of options, such as A3A_3 with 3 choices, A5A_5 with 2, and A7A_7 with 4?

Tip: When dealing with combinatorics problems involving choices and constraints, it often helps to break down the situation case-by-case, as we did here, to ensure that all dependencies are carefully accounted for.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Combinatorics
Set Theory
Conditional Probability

Formulas

2^3
2 × 2 × 3 × 3

Theorems

Fundamental Counting Principle
Product Rule of Counting

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 10-12