Math Problem Statement
Solution
I see you have uploaded an image showing a problem related to Banzhaf power distribution for a weighted voting system. You are asked to find the Banzhaf power distribution for different quota values (q = 100, 106, 112, and 149). The problem involves a voting system with weights [50, 40, 30, 20, 10].
To help you solve part (d), where the quota is , let’s go through the process.
General Steps to Calculate Banzhaf Power Distribution:
-
Identify Winning Coalitions: A coalition is a group of voters, and a winning coalition has a total weight greater than or equal to the quota . The critical voter in a coalition is one whose removal changes the coalition from winning to losing.
-
Identify Critical Voters: For each winning coalition, determine which voter(s) are critical.
-
Banzhaf Power Index Calculation: For each voter, count how many times they are critical across all winning coalitions. The Banzhaf power index for a voter is the ratio of the number of times they are critical to the total number of critical events for all voters.
For :
- Voter weights: 50, 40, 30, 20, 10.
- Quota .
Now, I will calculate the Banzhaf power distribution for . Let me proceed with that calculation.For the quota , the Banzhaf power distribution is:
Each voter has equal power in this case, with each having a Banzhaf power index of or .
Would you like further details on how the coalitions were formed, or do you have any other questions?
Here are some follow-up questions:
- How does the Banzhaf power index change when the quota is lowered?
- What happens if one voter has significantly more weight than the others?
- Can you explain why all voters have equal power in the case?
- How would you compute the Shapley-Shubik power index in this situation?
- What real-life scenarios are modeled by weighted voting systems?
Tip: In a weighted voting system, voters with larger weights tend to have more influence, but their actual power also depends on the quota and coalitions formed.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Banzhaf Power Index
Weighted Voting System
Combinatorics
Formulas
Banzhaf Power Index = (Number of times a voter is critical) / (Total number of critical events)
Theorems
Banzhaf Power Theorem
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate level or advanced high school students
Related Recommendation
Banzhaf Power Distribution for Weighted Voting System [50, 40, 30, 20, 10] with Quotas 100, 106, 112, 149
Banzhaf Power Distribution for Weighted Voting System with Quotas 20, 21, 24, 29
Banzhaf Power Distribution of Weighted Voting System (33: 19, 15, 14, 3)
Banzhaf Power Distribution for Weighted Voting System [8: 8, 4, 2, 1]
Banzhaf Power Distribution for Weighted Voting System with Quota 100