Math Problem Statement

Consider the subset of the real line A = (-inf, 0]. Which of the following are open sets (there may be more than 1 correct answer)? A) A \cap [0,1] B) A \cap (-inf,-1) C) A \cup {½} D) A \cup (-1,1) E) A \cup (0.1,1)

Solution

Let's analyze each of the options and determine if they form open sets within the real line R\mathbb{R}.

The set A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] is a subset of the real line, which includes all real numbers less than or equal to 0. This set is not open because it contains its boundary point, 0.

Option A: A[0,1]A \cap [0, 1]

This is the intersection of two sets: A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] and the closed interval [0,1][0, 1]. The intersection of these two sets is simply [0][0], since 00 is the only point that belongs to both AA and [0,1][0, 1].

  • [0][0] is a single point, and single points are not open in R\mathbb{R}.
  • Therefore, A is not an open set in this case.

Option B: A(,1)A \cap (-\infty, -1)

This is the intersection of the set A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] with the open interval (,1)(- \infty, -1). The intersection of these two sets is the interval (,1)(- \infty, -1), since the set (,1)(- \infty, -1) consists of all real numbers strictly less than 1-1, and these numbers are also in AA.

  • (,1)(- \infty, -1) is an open set in R\mathbb{R} because it does not include any boundary points (it has no points of closure in its interval).
  • Therefore, B is an open set.

Option C: A{1/2}A \cup \{1/2\}

This is the union of the set A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] with the single point {1/2}\{1/2\}. The set AA is already non-open as it contains the boundary point 00. Adding a single point {1/2}\{1/2\} does not make the set open, since the union of a non-open set with a point does not create an open set.

  • {1/2}\{1/2\} is a single point, and adding a single point to a non-open set does not result in an open set.
  • Therefore, C is not an open set.

Option D: A(1,1)A \cup (-1, 1)

This is the union of the set A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] with the open interval (1,1)(-1, 1). The union of these two sets will result in a set that includes all numbers less than or equal to 0 from AA and all the numbers strictly between 1-1 and 11 from (1,1)(-1, 1). The resulting union is the set (,1)(- \infty, 1), which is the open interval from - \infty to 11.

  • (,1)(- \infty, 1) is an open set because it does not include its boundary points, including 1.
  • Therefore, D is an open set.

Option E: A(0.1,1)A \cup (0.1, 1)

This is the union of the set A=(,0]A = (-\infty, 0] with the open interval (0.1,1)(0.1, 1). The set AA already includes all real numbers less than or equal to 0, and the interval (0.1,1)(0.1, 1) is a set of numbers strictly between 0.1 and 1. Thus, the union of these two sets is the set (,0](0.1,1)(-\infty, 0] \cup (0.1, 1), which contains two disjoint parts: the set (,0](-\infty, 0] and the set (0.1,1)(0.1, 1).

  • The set (,0](- \infty, 0] is not open, and adding the interval (0.1,1)(0.1, 1) does not make the union open, as the set (,0](- \infty, 0] includes the boundary point 0, which prevents the whole set from being open.
  • Therefore, E is not an open set.

Final Answers:

  • B: A(,1)A \cap (-\infty, -1) is an open set.
  • D: A(1,1)A \cup (-1, 1) is an open set.

Additional Questions:

  1. What does it mean for a set to be open in R\mathbb{R}?
  2. Why are single points in R\mathbb{R} not open sets?
  3. How do boundary points affect whether a set is open or not?
  4. What is the difference between open and closed intervals?
  5. Can the union of two non-open sets ever be open? Why or why not?

Tip:

Remember that a set is open if it does not include its boundary points and for every point in the set, there exists a small neighborhood around it that is entirely contained within the set.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Set Theory
Open and Closed Sets in Real Analysis
Intervals on the Real Line

Formulas

-

Theorems

Definition of Open Sets in Real Analysis
Properties of Intervals and their Openness

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Mathematics or Advanced High School (Grades 11-12)