Math Problem Statement

why is this the case where you add?

Why is this the case where you add?

Solution

In this solution, the projection of a vector v onto the subspace WW, spanned by two orthogonal vectors w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2}, is the sum of its projections onto the two orthogonal components. This process leverages the property of orthogonal projections.

Here’s a breakdown of why you add the projections:

  1. Orthogonal vectors don't interfere:

    • Since w1w2=0\mathbf{w_1} \cdot \mathbf{w_2} = 0, the two vectors w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2} span independent directions in the subspace WW. The projection of v onto WW needs to account for the contribution from both orthogonal components.
  2. Projection decomposes vector components:

    • To get the full projection of v\mathbf{v} onto the subspace WW, you first project v\mathbf{v} onto each basis vector: \quad \text{and} \quad \text{Proj}_{\mathbf{w_2}} \mathbf{v} = \frac{\mathbf{v} \cdot \mathbf{w_2}}{\mathbf{w_2} \cdot \mathbf{w_2}} \mathbf{w_2}.$$
  3. Adding results gives the total projection:

    • Since the two vectors are orthogonal, the total projection of v\mathbf{v} onto WW is simply: ProjWv=Projw1v+Projw2v.\text{Proj}_{W} \mathbf{v} = \text{Proj}_{\mathbf{w_1}} \mathbf{v} + \text{Proj}_{\mathbf{w_2}} \mathbf{v}.
    • Each projection captures how much of v lies in the direction of w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2}, respectively. The sum then reflects the complete projection of v onto the plane or subspace spanned by these vectors.

This idea works only because w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2} are orthogonal. If they weren’t orthogonal, the projections would not be independent, and a more complicated process involving Gram-Schmidt orthogonalization would be required.


Do you want further details or have any questions?

Here are five related questions to deepen your understanding:

  1. How does the orthogonality of two vectors affect their projections?
  2. What would happen if w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2} weren’t orthogonal?
  3. Can you explain the geometric intuition behind the sum of projections?
  4. How does projection change when dealing with higher-dimensional spaces?
  5. How does the result differ if v\mathbf{v} is not in the span of w1\mathbf{w_1} and w2\mathbf{w_2}?

Tip: Always check for orthogonality when working with projections, as it makes the computations much simpler!

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Vector Projections
Linear Algebra
Orthogonal Projections

Formulas

Proj_w1(v) = (v ⋅ w1 / w1 ⋅ w1) w1
Proj_w2(v) = (v ⋅ w2 / w2 ⋅ w2) w2
Proj_W(v) = Proj_w1(v) + Proj_w2(v)

Theorems

Orthogonal Projection Theorem

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate - Linear Algebra