Math Problem Statement

A piece of 8 × 10 8×10 white paper sits on a table. Let G G be the symmetries of this object that leave the paper covering the same part of the table as it starts. How many elements in G × Z 3 G×Z 3 ​ have order 3 3?

Solution

We need to analyze the symmetries of an 8×108 \times 10 white piece of paper that preserve its position on the table and determine how many elements in G×Z3G \times \mathbb{Z}_3 have order 3.

Step 1: Understanding GG

The group GG consists of the symmetries of a rectangle that leave it in the same place on the table. The allowed symmetries are:

  • The identity transformation ee.
  • 180180^\circ rotation (rr).
  • Reflections across the vertical axis (svs_v), the horizontal axis (shs_h), and the two diagonals (sds_d and sds_{d'}).

The dihedral group D2D_2 (or D4D_4 in general notation) describes these symmetries, giving us 8 elements: G={e,r,sv,sh,sd,sd,svh,sdd}G = \{ e, r, s_v, s_h, s_d, s_{d'}, s_{vh}, s_{dd'} \}

Step 2: Understanding Z3\mathbb{Z}_3

The group Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 consists of three elements: Z3={0,1,2}\mathbb{Z}_3 = \{0, 1, 2\} where each number represents multiplication by a primitive 3rd root of unity.

Step 3: Elements of Order 3 in G×Z3G \times \mathbb{Z}_3

An element (g,z)G×Z3(g, z) \in G \times \mathbb{Z}_3 has order 3 if and only if: (g,z)3=(e,0)(g, z)^3 = (e, 0)

This means that:

  1. g3=eg^3 = e in GG.
  2. zz must be a generator of Z3\mathbb{Z}_3, meaning z=1z = 1 or z=2z = 2.

Since GG has no elements of order 3 (as all elements square to identity or have order 2), the only way to achieve order 3 in G×Z3G \times \mathbb{Z}_3 is by picking g=eg = e (identity element), while zz is an element of order 3.

Step 4: Counting the Elements

Since GG has only one element of order 1 (identity ee), the valid elements of order 3 in G×Z3G \times \mathbb{Z}_3 are: (e,1),(e,2)(e, 1), (e, 2)

Thus, there are 2 elements of order 3.


Do you want a more detailed explanation or have any questions?

Here are 5 related questions:

  1. What are the properties of the dihedral group D4D_4 in general?
  2. How do we determine the order of an element in a direct product of groups?
  3. What would happen if the paper were a square instead of a rectangle?
  4. How does the order of elements in Zn\mathbb{Z}_n affect direct product group structures?
  5. What changes if we consider symmetries that allow flipping the paper over?

Tip: Always check the order of elements in individual groups before analyzing direct products.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Group Theory
Symmetry
Direct Product of Groups
Dihedral Groups

Formulas

Order of an element in a direct product: (g, z)^n = (e, 0)
Dihedral group D_2 symmetries
Elements of Z_3: {0, 1, 2}

Theorems

Group Order Theorem
Dihedral Group Symmetry Theorem

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate - Abstract Algebra