Math Problem Statement

Hannah sold short 100 shares of ABC stocks at its current price of $45. Assuming the initial margin is 60% and the maintenance margin is 30%.

a. A month later, ABC stock dropped to $40. What is her return on equity for this investment?

b. Assuming that ABC instead rose to $50. Calculate her new margin. What is the maximum price of ABC before she will receive a margin call?

Solution

Let's tackle the problem step by step.

Part (a) - ABC stock dropped to $40. What is Hannah's return on equity?

Initial Setup:

  • Number of shares sold short: 100
  • Initial stock price (when sold): $45
  • Stock price after one month: $40
  • Initial margin requirement: 60%
  • Maintenance margin: 30%

When Hannah sold the stock short at $45, she received 100×45=4500100 \times 45 = 4500 dollars. However, because of the initial margin requirement of 60%, she must deposit 60% of the value of the short sale as margin.

The margin required: Initial Margin=60%×4500=2700\text{Initial Margin} = 60\% \times 4500 = 2700

Thus, the total value in her margin account at the start is $2700.

When the price drops to $40:

Now, the stock price is $40, so her short position has changed in value. The new value of the short position: New Value of Short Position=100×40=4000\text{New Value of Short Position} = 100 \times 40 = 4000

Since Hannah sold at $45 and the price dropped to $40, she made a profit of: Profit=45004000=500\text{Profit} = 4500 - 4000 = 500

Her equity (the amount she now has in her margin account) is: Equity=Initial Margin+Profit=2700+500=3200\text{Equity} = \text{Initial Margin} + \text{Profit} = 2700 + 500 = 3200

Now, the return on equity (ROE) is the profit relative to her initial margin: Return on Equity=ProfitInitial Margin=5002700=0.1852 or 18.52%\text{Return on Equity} = \frac{\text{Profit}}{\text{Initial Margin}} = \frac{500}{2700} = 0.1852 \text{ or } 18.52\%


Part (b) - ABC stock rose to $50. What is her new margin, and what is the maximum price before a margin call?

When the price rises to $50:

Now, the new value of the short position is: New Value of Short Position=100×50=5000\text{New Value of Short Position} = 100 \times 50 = 5000

Hannah is losing money now because the stock price has increased. Her loss is: Loss=50004500=500\text{Loss} = 5000 - 4500 = 500

Her new equity is: Equity=Initial MarginLoss=2700500=2200\text{Equity} = \text{Initial Margin} - \text{Loss} = 2700 - 500 = 2200

To calculate her new margin (which is equity as a percentage of the short position's value): New Margin=EquityValue of Short Position=22005000=0.44 or 44%\text{New Margin} = \frac{\text{Equity}}{\text{Value of Short Position}} = \frac{2200}{5000} = 0.44 \text{ or } 44\%

So, her new margin is 44%.

Maximum price before a margin call:

A margin call occurs when her equity falls below the maintenance margin of 30%.

Let PP be the price at which Hannah will receive a margin call. At that point, her equity must be 30% of the value of the short position. The equity is also 2700(P×1004500)2700 - (P \times 100 - 4500), which represents her initial margin minus her losses.

At the margin call point: 2700(P×1004500)P×100=30%\frac{2700 - (P \times 100 - 4500)}{P \times 100} = 30\%

Solving for PP:

2700(P×1004500)=0.3×P×1002700 - (P \times 100 - 4500) = 0.3 \times P \times 100 2700100P+4500=30P2700 - 100P + 4500 = 30P 7200=130P7200 = 130P P=7200130=55.38P = \frac{7200}{130} = 55.38

So, the maximum price of ABC stock before Hannah receives a margin call is $55.38.


Do you want more details or have any questions?

Here are 5 follow-up questions related to this problem:

  1. What would be the return on equity if the stock price dropped to $35 instead?
  2. How much additional capital would Hannah need to deposit if the stock price reached $56?
  3. How would the initial margin requirement change if it were set at 50% instead of 60%?
  4. How does the maintenance margin affect the risk of margin calls for short sellers?
  5. What strategies could Hannah use to mitigate the risk of a margin call if the stock price rises?

Tip: When short selling, always monitor stock price movements carefully, as a rising price can quickly lead to losses and margin calls.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Short Selling
Margins
Profit and Loss Calculation
Percentage Calculation
Algebra

Formulas

Return on Equity = (Profit / Initial Margin)
Profit = Sale Price - Current Price
New Margin = (Equity / Value of Short Position)
Margin Call Price Formula: Initial Equity - (Price × Shares - Sale Price × Shares) = Maintenance Margin × Value of Short Position

Theorems

-

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 10-12