https://file.aiquickdraw.com/mathbot/file/1727942137418bu086kcx.jpg

Let's break down and solve the problem step by step.

### (a) Distribution using the method of sealed bids
The method of sealed bids works as follows:
1. Each participant bids privately for each item.
2. Items are awarded to the highest bidder, and those who win pay the average or fair share, compensating others if needed, based on their total valuations.

#### Valuations from Table 2:
- **Jean:** Bat $550, Glove $400
- **Jacques:** Bat $700, Glove $450
- **Gille:** Bat $550, Glove $400

Now, let's allocate the items:
- **For the bat:** Jacques values the bat highest at **$700**, so Jacques gets the bat.
- **For the glove:** Jacques again values the glove highest at **$450**, so Jacques gets the glove as well.

#### Total valuations:
- **Jean:** $550 + $400 = $950
- **Jacques:** $700 + $450 = $1,150
- **Gille:** $550 + $400 = $950

#### Total bid values for the items:
- **Bat:** $550 + $700 + $550 = **$1,800**
- **Glove:** $400 + $450 + $400 = **$1,250**
- Total value: $1,800 + $1,250 = **$3,050**

Jacques, having won both items, would owe the others compensation based on the proportional values they placed on the items.

To compute how much each participant owes or should receive, we divide the total value of the items by 3 (since there are three participants) to get the fair share for each person:
- **Fair share per person:** $3,050 ÷ 3 = **$1,016.67**

Since Jacques has won both items and valued them at **$1,150**, which is more than the fair share, Jacques will need to pay the difference:
- **Jacques pays:** $1,150 - $1,016.67 = **$133.33**

Jacques owes $133.33 to be distributed equally between Jean and Gille, since they did not win any items. Each of them receives:
- **Jean receives:** $133.33 ÷ 2 = **$66.67**
- **Gille receives:** $66.67 as well.

Thus, Jacques keeps the bat and glove and pays $66.67 to both Jean and Gille.

### (b) Manipulating bids beneficially
If Gille knew the bids of the others and could change her bids, she could strategically adjust her values to win at least one of the items or reduce her payout (if she doesn't value them much).

Let’s analyze the possible strategies:
1. **For the bat:** Since Jacques values the bat at $700, Gille could raise her bid for the bat just above Jean's ($550), say to **$551**. This way, Jacques would still win the bat, but Gille would increase the total bid pool, making Jacques pay more compensation.
   
2. **For the glove:** Gille could bid slightly higher than Jean’s bid for the glove (e.g., **$401**). Since Jacques would still win with a bid of $450, the extra $1 increases the total bid pool slightly, but Jacques would still have to pay a little more in compensation to Jean and Gille.

By manipulating her bids this way, Gille increases the total valuation for the items, forcing Jacques to pay a higher compensation without winning any of the items herself. She does this by bidding strategically just under Jacques' bids but above Jean's, to drive up the total valuation and force Jacques to pay more.

---

Let me know if you'd like further details or have questions! Here are five related questions you might explore:

1. How would the compensation change if Jean had won one item instead of Jacques winning both?
2. What happens if Gille values the items much lower than the others? How does that affect the distribution?
3. How does the sealed bid method compare to other methods of dividing goods, like the adjusted winner procedure?
4. Could there be a situation where everyone values an item equally? How would the division work then?
5. How would the total outcome change if the bids were weighted based on the number of participants?

**Tip:** In sealed bid auctions, strategic bidding can often involve slight over- or underbidding to either win an item or maximize compensation, depending on the goals of the participant.

Jean, Jacques, and Gille want to share an autographed cricket bat and glove. Using the method of sealed bids, they value the items as detailed in Table 2. How should the items be distributed? If Gille could change her bids given the bids of the others, how could she manipulate beneficially assuming that the initial bids were her true valuation for the goods?

Learn how to distribute an autographed cricket bat and glove using the sealed bid method based on participants' valuations. This problem explores fair division, proportional allocation, and compensation strategies in sealed bid auctions.

Math Problem Statement

Solution

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Formulas

Theorems

Suitable Grade Level

Related Recommendation