Math Problem Statement
Let A and B be events and let X and Y be the Bernoulli random variables corresponding to A and B ( X = ( 1, if the outcome is in A, 0, if the outcome is in Ac ). Show that A and B are independent (P rob(A and B) = P rob(A) × P rob(B)) if and only if X and Y are independent E(XnY m) = E(Xn ) E(Y m)
Solution
To show that and are independent if and only if the Bernoulli random variables and corresponding to these events are independent, we need to approach the problem in two parts.
1. Showing that and are independent implies and are independent.
Assumptions:
- and are independent events, which means:
Corresponding Bernoulli random variables:
- Let and be the Bernoulli random variables for events and respectively: \begin{cases} 1, & \text{if the outcome is in } A \\ 0, & \text{if the outcome is in } A^c \end{cases}$$ $$Y = \begin{cases} 1, & \text{if the outcome is in } B \\ 0, & \text{if the outcome is in } B^c \end{cases}$$
Objective:
We need to show that for all non-negative integers and when and are independent.
Proof:
Since and are Bernoulli random variables, their powers are simple:
- for any (since ),
- for any .
Thus, for any and , we are really proving:
Now, compute each term:
- (since when the outcome is in , and 0 otherwise),
- ,
- (since only if both and , which happens if and only if the outcome is in both and ).
Since and are independent, we have: Thus: Therefore, , which shows that and are independent.
2. Showing that and are independent implies and are independent.
Assumptions:
- and are independent random variables, which means:
Objective:
We need to show that this implies:
Proof:
As before, we know that:
- ,
- ,
- .
Since and are independent, we are given: Substituting the expressions for and , we get: This proves that and are independent.
Conclusion:
We have shown that and are independent if and only if the corresponding Bernoulli random variables and are independent, which completes the proof.
Follow-up questions:
- How do Bernoulli random variables differ from general random variables?
- What happens if and are dependent events? How does that affect the proof?
- Can this result be generalized to non-Bernoulli random variables?
- How can we extend this proof to more than two events?
- What is the significance of the expectation operator in proving independence?
Tip:
When dealing with Bernoulli random variables, remember that their powers are either 0 or 1, which simplifies many calculations involving products and expectations.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Probability Theory
Independence of Events
Bernoulli Random Variables
Expectation in Probability
Formulas
P(A ∩ B) = P(A) × P(B)
E(X^n Y^m) = E(X^n) E(Y^m)
Theorems
Independence of Random Variables
Bernoulli Distribution
Suitable Grade Level
Undergraduate (Probability and Statistics)
Related Recommendation
Understanding Independent Events and Complementary Independence in Probability
Prove Independence of Complement Events: α and B, A and β
Understanding Independent Events in Probability
Independent Events in Probability on a Uniform Set S = {1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6}
Proof: E(Y | X) = E(Y) When X and Y Are Independent