Math Problem Statement

true or false? Let x be a prime power (a number of the form pe where p is a prime number and e is a positive natural). Then it is possible that x divides a product ab, where a and b are each positive naturals, but x does not divide either a or b.

Solution

False.

If xx is a prime power, say x=pex = p^e where pp is a prime and ee is a positive integer, then for xx to divide the product abab, it must be that at least one of aa or bb contains enough factors of pp to contribute to the entire factor pep^e.

Here’s why:

  1. Prime Factorization Requirement: According to the properties of divisibility, if xx divides abab, then the exponent of pp in abab must be at least ee. That means either aa or bb must contain a factor of pp raised to at least the power ee (or higher).

  2. Contradiction Argument: Suppose xx divides abab, but xx does not divide either aa or bb. This implies that neither aa nor bb contain pp raised to at least the power ee. This would contradict the requirement for x=pex = p^e to divide abab.

Therefore, it is impossible for xx to divide abab without dividing either aa or bb.

Summary

If xx is a prime power pep^e, and xx divides abab, then xx must divide at least one of aa or bb. So, the statement is false.


Would you like a more detailed explanation or have any follow-up questions? Here are five related questions that might help:

  1. What if xx is a product of two distinct prime powers instead of a single prime power?
  2. How does this result extend to composite numbers instead of prime powers?
  3. Why is the property of prime numbers important for this conclusion?
  4. How would the proof differ if xx were a prime power with a different exponent?
  5. Can you explain what happens when aa and bb are relatively prime?

Tip: Understanding the properties of prime factorization and divisibility is crucial in many number theory problems. Always consider the role of the prime factors in each number!

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Number Theory
Divisibility
Prime Powers

Formulas

Divisibility rule for prime powers
Prime factorization

Theorems

Fundamental Theorem of Arithmetic
Divisibility properties of prime powers

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Level (Number Theory or Discrete Mathematics)