Math Problem Statement

QUESTION A DC motor operates by driving a current through a loop that is immersed in an external magnetic field. The interaction between the current and the external field creates a torque on the loop that causes it to rotate. A very simplified model of a DC motor is shown below.

Show that if the loop is a square of side length l = 5 [cm], the current is 𝐼0 = 600.0 [mA], and the external magnetic field strength is |H ̅ | = 5[kA/m], the maximum torque experienced by the loop is [𝐼0l^2μ0𝐻0] [Nm].

MY ANSWER: As shown in Lecture 6 Slide 3, the magnetic field H ̅, and magnetic flux density B ̅, are related as follows, where μ_0 is the permittivity of free space. B ̅=μ_0 H ̅ As shown in Lecture 5 Slide 8, in the presence of an external magnetic field, H ̅, a force is generated. If the section of wire where the force to be calculated is straight, and B ̅ is uniform then, as seen on this online source, we can define the force as F ⃗=I_0 l ⃗×B ̅ F ⃗=I_0 l ⃗×μ_0 H ̅_0 F=I_0 lμ_0 H_0 sin⁡(θ) Where l is the length of the wire. Similarly, as seen in Lecture 5 Slide 8, the torque (i.e. the turning moment of a force about an axis), is defined as follows τ ⃗=r ⃗×F ⃗ τ ⃗=r ⃗×(I_0 l ⃗×μ_0 H ̅_0 ) τ ⃗=r ⃗×(I_0 lμ_0 H_0 sin⁡(θ) ) τ=〖rI〗_0 lμ_0 H_0 sin^2⁡(θ)

Where r is the radius of the object being rotated.

MY QUESTIONS FOR YOU are there any mistakes in my answer so far? I am confused about how l and r related? have I defined these correctly? because I need them to actually be equal in order to get the equation in need to reach (shown in the question stem)

A DC motor operates by driving a current through a loop that is immersed in an external magnetic field. The interaction between the current and the external field creates a torque on the loop that causes it to rotate. A very simplified model of a DC motor is shown below. Show that if the loop is a square of side length l = 5 [cm], the current is 𝐼0 = 600.0 [mA], and the external magnetic field strength is |H ̅ | = 5[kA/m], the maximum torque experienced by the loop is [𝐼0l^2μ0𝐻0] [Nm].

Solution

Your approach is generally on the right track, but there are a few points of clarification to address regarding the relation between the side length ll and the torque radius rr, as well as a few minor adjustments in the derivation to reach the desired result.

Let's analyze your steps closely.

Understanding the Torque Formula

  • You correctly started by relating the magnetic flux density B\mathbf{B} to the magnetic field H\mathbf{H} using: B=μ0H\mathbf{B} = \mu_0 \mathbf{H} where μ0\mu_0 is the permeability of free space (not permittivity, which refers to ϵ0\epsilon_0).

  • The force on a current-carrying wire in a magnetic field is given by: F=I0l×B\mathbf{F} = I_0 \mathbf{l} \times \mathbf{B} or equivalently: F=I0lμ0H0sin(θ)F = I_0 l \mu_0 H_0 \sin(\theta) where θ\theta is the angle between the current element and the magnetic field.

Torque Expression

Torque τ\mathbf{\tau} is given by: τ=r×F\mathbf{\tau} = \mathbf{r} \times \mathbf{F} For a rectangular or square loop, the torque is maximized when the loop is oriented perpendicular to the magnetic field (i.e., θ=90\theta = 90^\circ, giving sin(θ)=1\sin(\theta) = 1).

Key Issue: Relation Between ll and rr

Here’s the important part:

  • ll is the side length of the square loop (which is given as 5 cm or 0.05 m).
  • rr represents the "lever arm" or distance from the axis of rotation to the point where the force is applied. For a square loop, this is typically half the side length, i.e.: r=l2r = \frac{l}{2} This is because the torque is generated about the center of the loop, and the force acts on the sides at a distance l2\frac{l}{2} from the axis of rotation.

Correcting the Torque Expression

Given the proper relation for rr, the torque is expressed as: τ=rI0lμ0H0sin(θ)\tau = r I_0 l \mu_0 H_0 \sin(\theta) Substitute r=l2r = \frac{l}{2}: τ=l2I0lμ0H0sin(θ)\tau = \frac{l}{2} I_0 l \mu_0 H_0 \sin(\theta) At maximum torque, sin(θ)=1\sin(\theta) = 1, so: τmax=l22I0μ0H0\tau_{\text{max}} = \frac{l^2}{2} I_0 \mu_0 H_0 This matches the form given in the problem statement up to a factor of 12\frac{1}{2}, and since the required expression was I0l2μ0H0I_0 l^2 \mu_0 H_0, this suggests that the model considers the torque contributions from multiple segments of the loop.

Summary of Corrections:

  1. rr (the effective lever arm) should be l2\frac{l}{2}, as the force acts at a distance half the side length of the square loop from the axis of rotation.
  2. When calculating torque, you need to account for this factor of 12\frac{1}{2}, leading to l22I0μ0H0\frac{l^2}{2} I_0 \mu_0 H_0 for the maximum torque.

Next Steps:

  1. Check if the lecture slides mention that the loop's symmetry leads to the final form of I0l2μ0H0I_0 l^2 \mu_0 H_0, omitting the factor of 12\frac{1}{2}.
  2. Review the problem's assumptions and whether the loop's geometry or number of turns affects this calculation.

Would you like a more detailed breakdown of the relationship between the geometry and torque?

Relative Questions:

  1. Why is the magnetic field B\mathbf{B} proportional to μ0H\mu_0 \mathbf{H}?
  2. How does changing the side length ll of the loop affect the torque?
  3. What is the physical meaning of the angle θ\theta in the torque equation?
  4. How would the torque expression change for a non-square rectangular loop?
  5. What role does μ0\mu_0 (permeability of free space) play in calculating electromagnetic forces?

Tip: When calculating torque, always be mindful of how the radius or lever arm is defined, especially in non-circular geometries.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Electromagnetism
Torque
Vector Calculus

Formulas

B̅ = μ0 H̅
F = I0 l⃗ × μ0 H̅0
τ = r⃗ × F⃗
τ = r I0 l μ0 H0 sin^2(θ)

Theorems

Biot-Savart Law
Torque in Magnetic Fields

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate (Physics/Electrical Engineering)