situation is that we had 6 coins, we kept 3 on each side of pan. the pan is not in equal state. we do not know if the fake coin is heavier or lighter

Given the situation with 6 coins, where 3 coins are placed on each side of the pan and the balance is not in a state of equilibrium, we need to identify the fake coin, knowing that it could be either heavier or lighter. 

### Analyzing the Current Situation:

1. **6 Coins Total**: 
   - Divided into two groups of 3 coins each.
   - The pan is not balanced, so one side is heavier than the other.

2. **Outcome of the Weighing**:
   - Since the balance is not in equilibrium, the fake coin must be in one of the two groups on the pan.
   - We still do not know whether the fake coin is heavier or lighter.

### Strategy to Identify the Fake Coin:

We know that the fake coin is among these 6 coins, and we need to determine which coin it is and whether it is heavier or lighter. Let's break it down step-by-step.

#### Step 1: Divide the Coins Further

We have two groups of 3 coins, and we know the fake coin is in one of these groups. Let's label the groups:

- Group A: 3 coins on the left pan.
- Group B: 3 coins on the right pan.

Assume:
- Group A is heavier than Group B.  
   This means:
  - **Possibility 1**: The fake coin is in Group A and it is heavier.
  - **Possibility 2**: The fake coin is in Group B and it is lighter.

#### Step 2: Second Weighing

Take **two coins from Group A** and **two coins from Group B**. Let's call them:

- Coins A1, A2 (from Group A)
- Coins B1, B2 (from Group B)

Now, weigh **A1 and B1** against **A2 and B2**.

- **Outcome 1: The balance is equal.**
  - If the balance is equal, it means that none of the coins A1, A2, B1, B2 is fake.
  - This leaves us with two possibilities:
    - The fake coin is the remaining one from Group A (A3) and it is heavier.
    - The fake coin is the remaining one from Group B (B3) and it is lighter.
  - **Next Step**: Weigh A3 against B3. 
    - If A3 is heavier, then A3 is the fake coin and it is heavier.
    - If B3 is lighter, then B3 is the fake coin and it is lighter.

- **Outcome 2: The balance is not equal.**
  - Assume A1, B1 (left side) is heavier than A2, B2 (right side). 
  - Then we have two scenarios:
    - **Scenario 1**: The fake coin is heavier, and it is either A1 or B1.
    - **Scenario 2**: The fake coin is lighter, and it is either A2 or B2.

#### Step 3: Third Weighing

Weigh **A1** against **B1** (assuming A1, B1 is heavier).

- **Outcome 1: The balance is equal.**
  - This means neither A1 nor B1 is the fake coin.
  - Therefore, the fake coin must be among A2 or B2, and it must be lighter.
  - Weigh A2 against a known genuine coin (from the original weighing).
  - If A2 is lighter, A2 is the fake coin.
  - Otherwise, B2 is the fake coin.

- **Outcome 2: The balance is not equal.**
  - If A1 is heavier than B1, then:
    - A1 is the fake coin and it is heavier.
  - If A1 is lighter than B1, then:
    - B1 is the fake coin and it is heavier.

### Conclusion:

You need **3 weighings** to identify the fake coin and determine whether it is heavier or lighter among the 6 coins in the given scenario.

---

Would you like a more detailed explanation, or do you have any questions?

### Related Questions:

1. How would the strategy change if there were 9 coins?
2. Can you solve the problem with 12 coins in 3 weighings?
3. What is the general strategy for identifying a fake coin among `n` coins with a balance scale?
4. How does the approach change if we know whether the fake coin is heavier or lighter beforehand?
5. How would the problem change if there were two fake coins instead of one?

#### Tip:
When dealing with problems involving balance scales, always try to maximize the information gained from each weighing by dividing coins into groups strategically.

Learn how to identify a fake coin among 6 coins using an unbalanced scale. This problem requires logical deduction and strategic weighing of coins to determine if the fake coin is heavier or lighter. Suitable for advanced problem-solving enthusiasts.

Math Problem Statement

Solution

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Formulas

Theorems

Suitable Grade Level

Related Recommendation