Math Problem Statement

Suppose a finite group G has exactly 2 proper nontrivial subgroups: a subgroup H of order p and a subgroup K of order q, where p and q are distinct primes. Prove that G is cyclic and determine its order

Solution

We are given that a finite group GG has exactly two proper nontrivial subgroups, a subgroup HH of order pp and a subgroup KK of order qq, where pp and qq are distinct primes. We need to prove that GG is cyclic and determine its order.

Step 1: Analyze the structure of GG

From the problem statement, we know that GG has exactly two proper nontrivial subgroups, one of order pp and the other of order qq. We can infer that these two subgroups must be distinct, as pqp \neq q (since pp and qq are distinct primes).

Since HH and KK are both proper subgroups, they must be contained in GG, and thus the order of GG must be a multiple of both pp and qq. Therefore, the order of GG, denoted G|G|, must be divisible by both pp and qq. Hence, the least common multiple of pp and qq gives a candidate for the order of GG. Since pp and qq are distinct primes, lcm(p,q)=pq\text{lcm}(p, q) = pq.

Thus, the order of GG must be G=pq|G| = pq.

Step 2: Verify the structure of GG

We now verify that GG is cyclic of order pqpq. If GG is cyclic, it must have an element gg of order pqpq. The subgroups of GG would then be the trivial subgroup, the subgroup generated by gpg^p (which would have order pp), and the subgroup generated by gqg^q (which would have order qq).

Since we are given that GG has exactly two proper nontrivial subgroups—one of order pp and one of order qq—the subgroups H=gpH = \langle g^p \rangle and K=gqK = \langle g^q \rangle must be exactly these two subgroups. Therefore, GG must be cyclic.

Step 3: Conclusion

Since GG is cyclic and its order is pqpq, the order of GG is exactly pqpq. Thus, we have shown that GG is cyclic and that its order is pqpq.

Summary of the steps:

  1. We used the fact that the order of GG must be divisible by both pp and qq to conclude that G=pq|G| = pq.
  2. We showed that if GG is cyclic of order pqpq, the two given subgroups of order pp and qq are precisely the subgroups of GG.
  3. Therefore, GG is cyclic and its order is pqpq.

Do you want more details about any part of this proof or have any questions?


Here are some follow-up questions to help deepen understanding:

  1. What is the structure of a cyclic group of order pqpq?
  2. How can we determine the number of subgroups of a finite group given its order?
  3. What happens if GG had more than two nontrivial proper subgroups? How would this affect the conclusion?
  4. How does the classification of cyclic groups of order pqpq help us understand the nature of groups of prime order?
  5. Why does the fact that pp and qq are distinct primes matter in this proof?

Tip: When proving properties about finite groups, always use group order and the Sylow theorems to reason about possible subgroups and their relations.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Group Theory
Cyclic Groups
Subgroup Structure
Divisibility

Formulas

Order of a group must be divisible by the order of its subgroups
Least Common Multiple (LCM) of primes

Theorems

Cyclic Group Theorem
Lagrange's Theorem
Fundamental Theorem of Cyclic Groups

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Mathematics