Problem:

Consider the following problem related to understanding contrapositives and abstract algebra.

Let $G$ be a finite group, and let $H$ be a subgroup of $G$. Suppose that for all elements $x \in G$, if $x^2 = e$ (where $e$ is the identity element), then $x \in H$.

1. Step 1: Prove or disprove the following statement: "If $H$ is a subgroup of $G$ and for all $x \in G$, $x^2 = e$ implies $x \in H$, then $H$ must contain all elements of order 2 in $G$."

2. Step 2: Consider the contrapositive of the statement: "If $x \notin H$, then $x^2 \neq e$."

   Is the contrapositive a correct logical deduction from the original hypothesis? Why or why not?

---

Expected Error:

A model could make a reasoning error by incorrectly applying the contrapositive logic.

• The common mistake is to interpret the contrapositive, "If $x \notin H$, then $x^2 \neq e$," as being logically equivalent to the original statement. However, this is incorrect in the context of groups and abstract algebra because the original statement only asserts something about elements satisfying $x^2 = e$, not about all elements of $G$.

• In abstract algebra, failing to recognize the difference between $x^2 = e$ applying specifically to elements of order 2 and misinterpreting the logical relationship between these sets leads to faulty reasoning.

Questions:

1. What is the difference between a statement and its contrapositive in mathematical logic?
2. In the context of groups, what does it mean for an element $x \in G$ to have order 2?
3. How does understanding contrapositives help in proving theorems in abstract algebra?
4. Can a contrapositive ever be false if the original statement is true? Why or why not?
5. How does the structure of a finite group $G$ affect the reasoning process in proving statements involving subgroups?

Tip:

When dealing with contrapositives in abstract algebra, always verify that the context allows for equivalence between the original statement and its contrapositive. Abstract algebra often deals with specific properties that need careful handling.