Math Problem Statement

For solving a linear system AX=b by conjugate gradient method, which of the following is true?

<b−Axj,Kj(A,b)>=1

Xj∈X0+Kj(A,b−Ax0)

the error ej has minimum norm

rj is orthogonal to a different space Kj(AT,b)

Solution

The correct statement for solving a linear system AX=bA X = b using the Conjugate Gradient Method is:

XjX0+Kj(A,bAX0)X_j \in X_0 + \mathcal{K}_j(A, b - A X_0)

This means that the solution at the jj-th iteration, XjX_j, lies in the initial guess X0X_0 plus the Krylov subspace Kj(A,bAX0)\mathcal{K}_j(A, b - A X_0). The Krylov subspace is spanned by vectors generated by repeated application of AA on the residual vector bAX0b - A X_0.

Why this is true:

The Conjugate Gradient (CG) method works by iterating over a Krylov subspace formed from the residuals. The Krylov subspace at the jj-th iteration is given by: Kj(A,bAX0)=span{r0,Ar0,A2r0,,Aj1r0}\mathcal{K}_j(A, b - A X_0) = \text{span} \{ r_0, A r_0, A^2 r_0, \dots, A^{j-1} r_0 \} where r0=bAX0r_0 = b - A X_0 is the initial residual.

Explanations for the other options:

  • bAxj,Kj(A,b)1\langle b - A x_j, \mathcal{K}_j(A, b) \rangle \geq 1: This inequality doesn't follow the structure of inner product relationships in the CG method.

  • The error eje_j has minimum norm: While the CG method minimizes the A-norm of the error at each step, this is not the complete statement.

  • rjr_j is orthogonal to a different space Kj(AT,b)\mathcal{K}_j(A^T, b): The residuals rjr_j are orthogonal to the Krylov subspace Kj(A,b)\mathcal{K}_j(A, b), not Kj(AT,b)\mathcal{K}_j(A^T, b).

Would you like more details on how the Conjugate Gradient method works?

Here are 5 related questions:

  1. What is the Krylov subspace in the Conjugate Gradient method?
  2. How does the Conjugate Gradient method minimize the error?
  3. Why is orthogonality of residuals important in the Conjugate Gradient method?
  4. How does the CG method handle symmetric positive definite matrices?
  5. Can the Conjugate Gradient method be applied to non-symmetric matrices?

Tip: In Conjugate Gradient, the residuals become orthogonal to the Krylov subspace, which ensures optimal convergence in finite steps.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Linear Algebra
Conjugate Gradient Method
Krylov Subspace
Residual Vector

Formulas

A X = b
X_j ∈ X_0 + 𝒦_j(A, b - A X_0)
r_0 = b - A X_0
𝒦_j(A, b - A X_0) = span{r_0, A r_0, A^2 r_0, ..., A^{j-1} r_0}

Theorems

Krylov Subspace Theorem
Orthogonality of Residuals in CG Method

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Level