Math Problem Statement

Let X be a metric space such that X is a union of open neighborhood. Show that if k is subset of X such that k is compact, then k is closed and bounded.

Solution

To prove that if KXK \subset X is compact in a metric space XX that is a union of open neighborhoods, then KK is closed and bounded, we will tackle each property (closed and bounded) separately.

1. Boundedness

We need to show that the compact set KK is bounded. A set KXK \subset X is bounded if there exists some real number M>0M > 0 and a point x0Xx_0 \in X such that:

d(x0,k)Mfor allkK.d(x_0, k) \leq M \quad \text{for all} \, k \in K.

Proof of boundedness:

  • Since KK is compact, by definition, every open cover of KK has a finite subcover.
  • Consider the family of open balls {B(x,n)}nN\{ B(x, n) \}_{n \in \mathbb{N}}, where B(x,n)B(x, n) denotes the open ball of radius nn centered at some point xXx \in X.
  • These open balls cover the entire space XX, which means that {B(x,n)}\{ B(x, n) \} forms an open cover for KK.
  • By the compactness of KK, there is a finite subcover, say {B(x,n1),B(x,n2),,B(x,nm)}\{ B(x, n_1), B(x, n_2), \dots, B(x, n_m) \}.
  • Let nmax=max{n1,n2,,nm}n_{\max} = \max\{n_1, n_2, \dots, n_m\}. This implies that KB(x,nmax)K \subset B(x, n_{\max}).
  • Therefore, KK is contained within a ball of finite radius, meaning KK is bounded.

2. Closedness

We need to show that KK is closed, meaning that if a sequence {xn}K\{x_n\} \subset K converges to some limit xXx \in X, then xKx \in K.

Proof of closedness:

  • Let {xn}\{x_n\} be a sequence in KK that converges to some point xXx \in X.
  • Since KK is compact, every sequence in KK has a convergent subsequence whose limit lies in KK.
  • But {xn}\{x_n\} already converges to xXx \in X. By the compactness of KK, this limit must also lie in KK, implying that xKx \in K.
  • Therefore, KK contains all its limit points, which means KK is closed.

Conclusion:

We have shown that if KXK \subset X is compact, then:

  • KK is bounded because it is contained in some large ball.
  • KK is closed because every convergent sequence in KK has its limit point within KK.

Thus, in a metric space XX that is a union of open neighborhoods, every compact set KK is closed and bounded.


Would you like further details or have any questions? Here are some related questions to expand on this topic:

  1. How does the Heine-Borel theorem relate to this result?
  2. What are the definitions of open and closed sets in metric spaces?
  3. Can you prove that every closed and bounded subset of Rn\mathbb{R}^n is compact?
  4. What happens if the metric space is not a union of open neighborhoods?
  5. How do compact sets behave in non-metric topological spaces?

Tip: In metric spaces, compact

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Metric Spaces
Compactness
Closed Sets
Bounded Sets

Formulas

d(x_0, k) ≤ M for all k ∈ K

Theorems

Compactness Theorem
Heine-Borel Theorem

Suitable Grade Level

University Level