Math Problem Statement
Solution
Let's solve this step by step:
Problem Breakdown:
A box contains balls of different colors:
- 1 black ball
- 2 blue balls
- 3 green balls
- 4 yellow balls
- 5 red balls
- 6 white balls
The question involves two statements:
- Statement 1: The smallest number such that any balls drawn randomly must contain at least one complete group of one color is 21.
- Statement 2: The smallest number such that any balls drawn randomly must contain at least one ball of each color is 16.
Let's analyze each statement individually.
Statement 1 Analysis:
The smallest ensures that at least one full group (all balls of a single color) is drawn. To calculate this:
- The maximum number of balls that can be drawn without completing any color is the sum of the maximum possible incomplete draws:
- Black: (can't avoid taking the 1 black ball, as it's the only one).
- Blue: (can take at most 1 of the 2 blue balls without completing blue).
- Green: (can take at most 2 of the 3 green balls).
- Yellow: (can take at most 3 of the 4 yellow balls).
- Red: (can take at most 4 of the 5 red balls).
- White: (can take at most 5 of the 6 white balls).
Thus, the total is:
To ensure one complete group, we must draw one more ball. Therefore:
Statement 1 is incorrect as it claims .
Statement 2 Analysis:
The smallest ensures that at least one ball of each color is drawn. To calculate this:
- To avoid having at least one ball of every color, we can maximize the number of balls drawn from all but one color:
- Blue, green, yellow, red, and white: .
So, if we draw 20 balls, it's possible to miss the black ball. To ensure at least one ball of every color, we need to draw one more ball. Therefore:
Statement 2 is incorrect as it claims .
Final Answer:
Neither statement 1 nor statement 2 is correct.
Correct option: (d) Neither 1 nor 2
Would you like a more detailed explanation or examples?
Related Questions:
- How would the result change if the number of balls of each color were doubled?
- Can this problem be solved using probability instead of combinatorics?
- How does the pigeonhole principle apply to these types of problems?
- What is the general formula for finding and in such problems?
- What if the box also included additional colors or objects (e.g., shapes or sizes)?
Tip:
Always verify the logic by simulating scenarios with smaller numbers to check for boundary cases.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Pigeonhole Principle
Combinatorics
Optimization
Formulas
Maximum incomplete group formula: Sum of (total balls of each color - 1)
Minimum required balls for full group: Total incomplete + 1
Minimum required balls for at least one of each color: Total balls - maximum from one color + 1
Theorems
Pigeonhole Principle
Suitable Grade Level
Grades 10-12
Related Recommendation
Minimum Balls Drawn to Ensure Color Counts
Using Pigeonhole Principle: Ensuring 12 Balls of the Same Color
Pigeonhole Principle: Minimum Number of Students to Ensure Three Have the Same Grade
Minimum Number of Balls to Guarantee One of Each Color
Combinatorics Problem: Forming Pairs of Distinct Colored Balls