Math Problem Statement

  1. Calculate the total time required to transfer a 1.5-MB file in the following cases, assuming an RTT of 80 ms, a packet size of 1 KB data, and an initial 2 × RTT of “handshaking” before data is sent: (a) The bandwidth is 10 Mbps, and data packets can be sent continuously. (b) The bandwidth is 10 Mbps, but after we finish sending each data packet we must wait one RTT before sending the next. (c) The link allows infinitely fast transmit, but limits bandwidth such that only 20 packets can be sent per RTT. (d) Zero transmit time as in (c), but during the first RTT we can send one packet, during the second RTT we can send two packets, during the third we can send four (2 3−1 ), etc. (A justification for such an exponential increase will be given in Chapter 6.)

Solution

To solve this problem, we'll calculate the total time required to transfer a 1.5-MB file under the given conditions. Let's first break down the problem:

  • File Size: 1.5 MB = 1.5×1024×10241.5 \times 1024 \times 1024 bytes = 1,572,864 bytes.
  • RTT (Round-Trip Time): 80 ms = 0.08 seconds.
  • Packet Size: 1 KB = 1024 bytes.
  • Number of Packets: Total packets required = 1,572,864 bytes1024 bytes/packet\frac{1,572,864 \text{ bytes}}{1024 \text{ bytes/packet}} = 1536 packets.

(a) Bandwidth is 10 Mbps, and data packets can be sent continuously.

  • Bandwidth: 10 Mbps = 10×10610 \times 10^6 bits per second.
  • Packet Size: 1 KB = 1024 bytes = 8192 bits.

Time to send one packet: Transmission time per packet=Packet SizeBandwidth=8192 bits10×106 bits/sec=0.0008192 seconds\text{Transmission time per packet} = \frac{\text{Packet Size}}{\text{Bandwidth}} = \frac{8192 \text{ bits}}{10 \times 10^6 \text{ bits/sec}} = 0.0008192 \text{ seconds}

Total transmission time for 1536 packets: Total Transmission Time=1536×0.0008192 seconds=1.25952 seconds\text{Total Transmission Time} = 1536 \times 0.0008192 \text{ seconds} = 1.25952 \text{ seconds}

Total time required: Total Time=2×RTT+Total Transmission Time=2×0.08 seconds+1.25952 seconds=1.41952 seconds\text{Total Time} = 2 \times \text{RTT} + \text{Total Transmission Time} = 2 \times 0.08 \text{ seconds} + 1.25952 \text{ seconds} = 1.41952 \text{ seconds}

(b) Bandwidth is 10 Mbps, but after we finish sending each data packet, we must wait one RTT before sending the next.

Time to send one packet and wait for an RTT: Time per packet=Transmission time+RTT=0.0008192 seconds+0.08 seconds=0.0808192 seconds\text{Time per packet} = \text{Transmission time} + \text{RTT} = 0.0008192 \text{ seconds} + 0.08 \text{ seconds} = 0.0808192 \text{ seconds}

Total time required: Total Time=2×RTT+1536×0.0808192 seconds=0.16 seconds+124.456512 seconds=124.616512 seconds\text{Total Time} = 2 \times \text{RTT} + 1536 \times 0.0808192 \text{ seconds} = 0.16 \text{ seconds} + 124.456512 \text{ seconds} = 124.616512 \text{ seconds}

(c) Infinitely fast transmit, but only 20 packets can be sent per RTT.

  • Number of RTTs needed: Number of RTTs=1536 packets20 packets/RTT=76.8=77 RTTs\text{Number of RTTs} = \left\lceil \frac{1536 \text{ packets}}{20 \text{ packets/RTT}} \right\rceil = \left\lceil 76.8 \right\rceil = 77 \text{ RTTs}

Total time required: Total Time=2×RTT+77×0.08 seconds=0.16 seconds+6.16 seconds=6.32 seconds\text{Total Time} = 2 \times \text{RTT} + 77 \times 0.08 \text{ seconds} = 0.16 \text{ seconds} + 6.16 \text{ seconds} = 6.32 \text{ seconds}

(d) Zero transmit time, but exponential increase in packets per RTT.

  • Packets sent in each RTT:
    • RTT 1: 1 packet
    • RTT 2: 2 packets
    • RTT 3: 4 packets
    • ...
    • RTT n:2n1 packets\text{RTT } n: 2^{n-1} \text{ packets}

Sum of packets up to RTT nn: Total packets sent by RTT n=1+2+4+...+2n1=2n1\text{Total packets sent by RTT } n = 1 + 2 + 4 + ... + 2^{n-1} = 2^n - 1

Finding the smallest nn such that 2n115362^n - 1 \geq 1536: 2n115362n1537nlog2153710.562^n - 1 \geq 1536 \Rightarrow 2^n \geq 1537 \Rightarrow n \geq \log_2{1537} \approx 10.56

So n=11n = 11 RTTs.

Total time required: Total Time=2×RTT+11×0.08 seconds=0.16 seconds+0.88 seconds=1.04 seconds\text{Total Time} = 2 \times \text{RTT} + 11 \times 0.08 \text{ seconds} = 0.16 \text{ seconds} + 0.88 \text{ seconds} = 1.04 \text{ seconds}

Summary of Results

  • (a): 1.41952 seconds
  • (b): 124.616512 seconds
  • (c): 6.32 seconds
  • (d): 1.04 seconds

Would you like more details or have any questions? Here are some additional questions to consider:

  1. How does increasing RTT affect the overall transmission time in scenario (a)?
  2. What would happen to the transmission time if the packet size was doubled in scenario (b)?
  3. How does reducing the number of packets per RTT in scenario (c) affect the total time?
  4. Can you derive a general formula for transmission time based on the number of RTTs and bandwidth?
  5. What are some practical scenarios where the exponential packet increase in scenario (d) could be used?

Tip: In network transmissions, minimizing RTTs or optimizing the packet size relative to bandwidth can significantly reduce total transmission time.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Network Transmission
Bandwidth
RTT (Round-Trip Time)
Packet Transmission

Formulas

Transmission time per packet = Packet Size / Bandwidth
Total Transmission Time = Number of Packets * Transmission time per packet

Theorems

-

Suitable Grade Level

Advanced