Math Problem Statement

You must decide whether to buy a new car for $33,100 or lease the same car over a three-year period. Under the terms of the lease, you can make a down payment of $3000 and have monthly payments of $380. At the end of the three years, the leased car has a residual value (the amount you pay if you choose to buy the car at the end of the lease period) of $20,600. Assume you can sell the new car at the end of the three years at the same residual value. Is it less expensive to buy or to lease?

Solution

To determine whether buying or leasing is less expensive, we need to calculate the total costs of both options over the three-year period and compare them. Let's break this into steps:


1. Buying the Car

  • Purchase price: $33,100
  • Residual value (sale price after 3 years): $20,600
  • Total cost for buying: Total Cost=Purchase PriceResidual Value\text{Total Cost} = \text{Purchase Price} - \text{Residual Value} Total Cost=33,10020,600=12,500\text{Total Cost} = 33,100 - 20,600 = 12,500

2. Leasing the Car

  • Down payment: $3,000
  • Monthly payments: $380 for 36 months (3 years): Total Lease Payments=380×36=13,680\text{Total Lease Payments} = 380 \times 36 = 13,680
  • Residual value (to purchase at the end of the lease): $20,600

Case A: Not Buying the Leased Car at the End

  • Total lease cost: Total Cost=Down Payment+Total Lease Payments\text{Total Cost} = \text{Down Payment} + \text{Total Lease Payments} Total Cost=3,000+13,680=16,680\text{Total Cost} = 3,000 + 13,680 = 16,680

Case B: Buying the Leased Car at the End

  • Total cost if you purchase at the end: Total Cost=Down Payment+Total Lease Payments+Residual Value\text{Total Cost} = \text{Down Payment} + \text{Total Lease Payments} + \text{Residual Value} Total Cost=3,000+13,680+20,600=37,280\text{Total Cost} = 3,000 + 13,680 + 20,600 = 37,280

Comparison

  1. Buying: $12,500
  2. Leasing (not buying the car at the end): $16,680
  3. Leasing (buying the car at the end): $37,280

Conclusion

  • Cheapest Option: Buying the car outright is less expensive at $12,500.
  • Leasing (even without buying the car at the end) is more costly, at $16,680.

If your goal is to minimize costs, buying the car outright is the better choice.


Do you have any questions, or would you like further details?

Here are five related questions to expand this analysis:

  1. How do interest rates affect the cost of financing the purchase?
  2. What are the potential maintenance costs of buying versus leasing a car?
  3. How does depreciation impact the car's resale value over time?
  4. Can leasing provide benefits beyond costs, such as flexibility or warranty coverage?
  5. What factors should you consider in deciding whether to keep or sell a car after three years?

Tip: When comparing long-term costs, always consider hidden costs like insurance and maintenance!

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Cost Analysis
Basic Arithmetic
Comparison of Alternatives

Formulas

Total Cost (Buying) = Purchase Price - Residual Value
Total Cost (Leasing without Buying) = Down Payment + Monthly Payment × Months
Total Cost (Leasing with Buying) = Down Payment + Monthly Payment × Months + Residual Value

Theorems

-

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 10-12