Math Problem Statement
A clinical psychologist is interested in assessing the effectiveness of two therapies for bipolar disorder (manic depression). They identify 15 individuals (N) diagnosed with this disorder and randomly assigns them to one of three groups: (a) no treatment (b) psychotherapy, (c) psychotherapy in conjunction with psychoactive medication. The psychologist subsequently measures their level of symptomatology (higher scores reflect poorer functioning). Assume the data are as follows:
Group/Level Mean n No Treatment 10 5 Psychotherapy 9.6 5 Psychotherapy & Medication 4.8 5
ANOVA Summary Table
SS df MS F Between 83.732 Within 416.268 Total
Which two are acceptable null hypotheses?
Group of answer choices
μ(1) - μ(2) - μ(3) = 0
There is no difference between the means of the groups
There is at least one group with a different mean
μ(1) = μ(2) = μ(3) = 0
μ(1) = μ(2) = μ(3)
Solution
In the context of an ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) to compare the effectiveness of different treatments for bipolar disorder, the null hypothesis generally states that there is no difference in means between the groups being compared. From the provided options, the two acceptable null hypotheses are:
- There is no difference between the means of the groups.
- μ(1) = μ(2) = μ(3)
These hypotheses assert that the means of the symptomatology scores for the three groups (no treatment, psychotherapy, and psychotherapy with medication) are equal, indicating that there is no effect of the treatment on symptomatology.
The other options provided are not appropriate null hypotheses for the following reasons:
- μ(1) - μ(2) - μ(3) = 0: This is not a standard way of expressing a null hypothesis in the context of ANOVA.
- There is at least one group with a different mean: This is actually the alternative hypothesis, which states that there is a significant difference between at least one pair of group means.
- μ(1) = μ(2) = μ(3) = 0: This would imply that the mean symptomatology score for all groups is zero, which is not relevant to the comparison of treatment effects.
Would you like to go into the details of the ANOVA calculation or have any specific questions about this setup?
Here are 5 questions you might ask next:
- How do you calculate the F-ratio in an ANOVA?
- What are the assumptions of ANOVA?
- How do you interpret the results of an ANOVA test?
- What is the difference between a null hypothesis and an alternative hypothesis?
- Can you explain how post hoc tests are used following an ANOVA?
Tip: When comparing more than two groups, ANOVA is a powerful statistical method to determine if there are any statistically significant differences among the group means.
Ask a new question for Free
By Image
Drop file here or Click Here to upload
Math Problem Analysis
Mathematical Concepts
Analysis of Variance (ANOVA)
Hypothesis Testing
Statistical Inference
Formulas
-
Theorems
-
Suitable Grade Level
Advanced Undergraduate or Graduate
Related Recommendation
ANOVA Test for Antidepressant Efficacy Using Depression Scores
Statistical Analysis of Coping, Anxiety, and Training Effectiveness
ANOVA Analysis for Three Treatment Conditions Using SPSS
ANOVA Test: Analysis of Depression Scores with Example Solution
Solve ANOVA Problem: Comparing Depression Scores Across Groups