Math Problem Statement

Explain the unbiasedness criteria of a good estimator. Suppose that you have two biased estimators of the same population parameter. Estimator A has a bias equal to 1/n (that is, the mean of the estimator is 1/n unit away from the parameter it estimates), where n is the sample size used. Estimator B has a bias equal to 0.01 (the mean of the estimator is 0.01 unit away from the parameter of interest). Under what condition/s is estimator A better than B?

Solution

Explanation of the Unbiasedness Criterion of a Good Estimator

An estimator is unbiased if the expected value of the estimator equals the true population parameter it estimates. Mathematically, for an estimator θ^\hat{\theta} of a parameter θ\theta, it is unbiased if: E[θ^]=θE[\hat{\theta}] = \theta This ensures that on average, across many samples, the estimator provides the correct parameter value.

However, in real-world scenarios, estimators may have some bias due to practical constraints. The bias of an estimator is defined as: Bias(θ^)=E[θ^]θ\text{Bias}(\hat{\theta}) = E[\hat{\theta}] - \theta

In this problem, we compare two biased estimators of the same population parameter.

Comparison Between Estimators A and B

  1. Bias of Estimator A:

    • Bias = 1/n1/n, which depends on the sample size nn.
    • As nn increases, 1/n01/n \to 0, reducing the bias.
  2. Bias of Estimator B:

    • Bias = 0.01, which is constant and independent of nn.

When is Estimator A Better?

Estimator A becomes better than Estimator B under the condition that its bias 1/n1/n is less than 0.01. Mathematically: 1n<0.01    n>100\frac{1}{n} < 0.01 \implies n > 100

Thus, Estimator A is better than Estimator B when the sample size n>100n > 100 because the bias of Estimator A becomes smaller than that of Estimator B.

Summary

  • Estimator A: Bias decreases with larger sample size.
  • Estimator B: Bias remains constant at 0.01.
  • Conclusion: Estimator A is preferred when n>100n > 100.

Do you want a deeper explanation or have specific questions?

Here are five related questions to expand your understanding:

  1. What are the implications of bias in statistical estimation?
  2. How does sample size influence the performance of an estimator?
  3. Can you explain the trade-off between bias and variance in estimation?
  4. Are there situations where a biased estimator is preferable to an unbiased one?
  5. How is the Mean Squared Error (MSE) used to evaluate the overall performance of estimators?

Tip: Always consider both bias and variance when evaluating estimators; a trade-off often exists to minimize overall error.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Statistical Estimation
Bias of Estimators
Unbiasedness Criterion

Formulas

Bias(\hat{\theta}) = E[\hat{\theta}] - \theta

Theorems

-

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate (Statistics)