Math Problem Statement

Let p and q be positive integers satisfying p < q and p + q = k. What is the smallest value of k that does not determine p and q uniquely?

Solution

The problem asks us to find the smallest value of kk such that pp and qq are not uniquely determined given the conditions:

  1. pp and qq are positive integers.
  2. p<qp < q.
  3. p+q=kp + q = k.

Solution:

To determine when pp and qq are not uniquely determined, we analyze the possible values of kk step by step:

  1. Case k=3k = 3:
    p+q=3p + q = 3, with p<qp < q. The only solution is p=1,q=2p = 1, q = 2.
    Unique solution.

  2. Case k=4k = 4:
    p+q=4p + q = 4, with p<qp < q. The only solution is p=1,q=3p = 1, q = 3.
    Unique solution.

  3. Case k=5k = 5:
    p+q=5p + q = 5, with p<qp < q. The only solution is p=2,q=3p = 2, q = 3.
    Unique solution.

  4. Case k=6k = 6:
    p+q=6p + q = 6, with p<qp < q. Possible pairs:

    • p=1,q=5p = 1, q = 5.
    • p=2,q=4p = 2, q = 4.

    Here, there are two solutions, so pp and qq are not uniquely determined.


Conclusion:

The smallest value of kk for which pp and qq are not uniquely determined is k=6k = 6.

Answer: (d) 6


Would you like a detailed breakdown of each case or more information about the reasoning?

Here are 5 related questions for further exploration:

  1. What happens if the condition p<qp < q is removed?
  2. Can kk be a non-integer value for this problem?
  3. How does the uniqueness of pp and qq depend on the parity (even/odd nature) of kk?
  4. What if pp and qq must both be prime numbers?
  5. How would the problem change if p+q=kp + q = k and p=qp = q were allowed?

Tip: Always verify constraints step by step for mathematical problems to avoid skipping potential cases!

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Number Theory
Inequalities
Integer Solutions

Formulas

p + q = k

Theorems

Basic properties of integers
Uniqueness of solutions under constraints

Suitable Grade Level

Grades 9-12