Math Problem Statement

Let G be a group. An element of G that can be expressed in the form aba−1b−1 for some a,b∈G is a commutator in G. The preceding exercise shows that there is a smallest normal subgroup C of a group G containing all commutators in G; the subgroup C is the commutator subgroup of G. Show that G/C is an abelian group.

Solution

To show that G/CG / C is an abelian group, we need to prove that for any two elements g1Cg_1C and g2Cg_2C in the quotient group G/CG / C, their product satisfies the commutative property:

g1Cg2C=g2Cg1Cg_1C \cdot g_2C = g_2C \cdot g_1C

Step-by-step Proof:

  1. Recall the definition of G/CG / C:

    • CC is the commutator subgroup of GG. It is the smallest normal subgroup of GG that contains all commutators of GG. A commutator is an element of the form aba1b1aba^{-1}b^{-1} for some a,bGa, b \in G.
    • The quotient group G/CG / C consists of cosets of the form gCgC, where gGg \in G.
  2. Commutativity in G/CG / C:

    • We want to show that for any g1,g2Gg_1, g_2 \in G, the cosets g1Cg_1C and g2Cg_2C commute, i.e., g1Cg2C=g2Cg1Cg_1C \cdot g_2C = g_2C \cdot g_1C.
  3. Expand both products: g1Cg2C=(g1g2)Cg_1C \cdot g_2C = (g_1g_2)C and g2Cg1C=(g2g1)C.g_2C \cdot g_1C = (g_2g_1)C.

  4. Relating these two products:

    • The products g1g2g_1g_2 and g2g1g_2g_1 differ by the commutator of g1g_1 and g2g_2: g1g2=g2g1[g1,g2],g_1g_2 = g_2g_1 \cdot [g_1, g_2], where [g1,g2]=g1g2g11g21[g_1, g_2] = g_1g_2g_1^{-1}g_2^{-1} is the commutator of g1g_1 and g2g_2.
  5. Use the fact that CC contains all commutators:

    • Since CC is the commutator subgroup, the commutator [g1,g2]C[g_1, g_2] \in C. Therefore, we can write: g1g2=g2g1cg_1g_2 = g_2g_1 \cdot c for some cCc \in C.
  6. In the quotient group G/CG / C:

    • In the quotient group, elements of CC are equivalent to the identity element. Therefore, we have: (g1g2)C=(g2g1c)C=(g2g1)C,(g_1g_2)C = (g_2g_1c)C = (g_2g_1)C, because cCc \in C, so multiplying by cc does not change the coset.
  7. Conclusion:

    • Thus, g1Cg2C=g2Cg1Cg_1C \cdot g_2C = g_2C \cdot g_1C, which means that G/CG / C is an abelian group.

Final Statement:

Since G/CG / C satisfies the commutative property, we conclude that G/CG / C is an abelian group.


Would you like a more detailed explanation of any specific part of this proof?

Here are 5 related questions to expand on this topic:

  1. What is the significance of a commutator in group theory?
  2. Why is the commutator subgroup the smallest normal subgroup containing all commutators?
  3. How can we interpret the structure of the quotient group G/CG / C geometrically?
  4. How does the commutator subgroup relate to solvable groups?
  5. Can we provide an example of a group GG where the commutator subgroup is non-trivial?

Tip: A group is abelian if and only if its commutator subgroup is trivial.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Group Theory
Commutators
Quotient Groups
Abelian Groups

Formulas

Commutator: [a, b] = aba^{-1}b^{-1}
Quotient group: G / C

Theorems

A quotient group G / C, where C is the commutator subgroup, is abelian.

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate Level