Math Problem Statement

A manager is constrained to spend $1,000,000 on projects. The initial costs and net present values (NPVs) of projects she is considering are as follows: Initial Cost NPV Project A $500,000 $300,000 Project B $1,000,000 $400,000 Project C $250,000 $200,000 Project D $750,000 $550,000 Project E $500,000

Which projects should she select?

$250,000

Solution

The manager's goal is to maximize the Net Present Value (NPV) of the projects while staying within the budget constraint of $1,000,000. Let's analyze the projects with their costs and NPVs, and find which combination maximizes the total NPV without exceeding $1,000,000.

Here are the projects and their details:

ProjectInitial CostNPV
A$500,000$300,000
B$1,000,000$400,000
C$250,000$200,000
D$750,000$550,000
E$500,000$250,000

The total budget is $1,000,000.

Step 1: Sort projects by NPV-to-cost ratio

To maximize NPV, it's beneficial to consider the NPV-to-cost ratio:

  • Project A: 300,000500,000=0.6\frac{300,000}{500,000} = 0.6
  • Project B: 400,0001,000,000=0.4\frac{400,000}{1,000,000} = 0.4
  • Project C: 200,000250,000=0.8\frac{200,000}{250,000} = 0.8
  • Project D: 550,000750,0000.73\frac{550,000}{750,000} \approx 0.73
  • Project E: 250,000500,000=0.5\frac{250,000}{500,000} = 0.5

Thus, the best strategy is to select projects that provide the highest NPV-to-cost ratio first, while staying within the budget.

Step 2: Select projects that maximize the total NPV within the budget

  • Start with Project C (Cost: $250,000, NPV: $200,000) since it has the highest NPV-to-cost ratio.
  • Next, select Project D (Cost: $750,000, NPV: $550,000), as this will maximize the total NPV.

The total cost is $250,000 + $750,000 = $1,000,000, which is within the budget.

Total NPV:

The total NPV for selecting Project C and Project D is: 200,000+550,000=750,000200,000 + 550,000 = 750,000

Conclusion:

The manager should select Project C and Project D, giving a total NPV of $750,000.

Would you like further details on how this was calculated or have any other questions?


Here are 5 questions that build on this information:

  1. How does changing the budget constraint affect the project selection?
  2. What if the NPV for Project A increases to $400,000? Would this change the decision?
  3. What impact does the cost of capital have on the NPV in project selection?
  4. Can this problem be solved using a linear programming approach?
  5. How does risk factor into the decision when comparing NPVs?

Tip: Always look at NPV-to-cost ratios when trying to maximize returns within a constrained budget!

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Optimization
Net Present Value (NPV)
Budget Constraints

Formulas

NPV-to-cost ratio = NPV / Initial Cost
Total NPV = sum of NPVs for selected projects

Theorems

Greedy algorithm for maximizing returns under budget constraints

Suitable Grade Level

College/University level (Finance, Economics)