Math Problem Statement

examples of clopen subsets

Solution

In topology, a clopen set is a set that is both open and closed in a given topological space. The existence of clopen sets depends on the specific topology defined on the space.

Here are some examples of clopen subsets:


1. Trivial Example in the Discrete Topology

  • In a discrete topology, every subset of the space is open and closed.
  • For example:
    • Let X={1,2,3}X = \{1, 2, 3\}.
    • The topology τ\tau consists of all subsets of XX:
      τ={,{1},{2},{3},{1,2},{1,3},{2,3},X}\tau = \{\emptyset, \{1\}, \{2\}, \{3\}, \{1, 2\}, \{1, 3\}, \{2, 3\}, X\}.
    • Here, every subset is clopen because it is both open (by definition of the discrete topology) and closed (its complement is also open).

2. Clopen Sets in the Indiscrete (Trivial) Topology

  • In the indiscrete topology, the only clopen sets are \emptyset (the empty set) and XX (the entire space).
  • For example:
    • Let X={a,b}X = \{a, b\}.
    • The topology τ\tau is {,X}\{\emptyset, X\}.
    • Both \emptyset and XX are clopen because:
      • They are open by definition, and
      • Their complements are also in τ\tau.

3. Clopen Sets in R\mathbb{R} with the Usual Topology

  • In the usual topology on the real numbers R\mathbb{R}, the only clopen sets are:
    • The empty set \emptyset, and
    • The entire space R\mathbb{R}.
  • This result follows from the connectedness of R\mathbb{R}, which means no nontrivial subset can be both open and closed.

4. Clopen Sets in a Finite Topological Space

  • In any finite topological space, clopen sets often arise naturally:
    • For example, let X={a,b}X = \{a, b\} with the topology τ={,{a},X}\tau = \{\emptyset, \{a\}, X\}.
    • Here, the subsets \emptyset, XX, and {a}\{a\} are all clopen because their complements are also open.

5. Clopen Sets in a Two-Point Space (Sierpiński Space)

  • Consider X={a,b}X = \{a, b\} with the topology τ={,{a},{a,b}}\tau = \{\emptyset, \{a\}, \{a, b\} \}:
    • \emptyset and XX are clopen.
    • {a}\{a\} is not clopen because its complement {b}\{b\} is not open.

Summary Table of Examples

SpaceClopen Sets
Discrete SpaceAll subsets
Indiscrete Space\emptyset and XX
R\mathbb{R} with usual topology\emptyset and R\mathbb{R}
Finite SpacesVaries based on the topology

Would you like further details on any of these examples or more complex scenarios?

Related Questions:

  1. Why are clopen sets significant in topology?
  2. How can we prove that R\mathbb{R} has no nontrivial clopen sets?
  3. What is the role of connectedness in determining clopen sets?
  4. Can a set be clopen in one topology but not in another?
  5. What are clopen sets in the context of metric spaces?

Tip: In a connected space, the only clopen sets are \emptyset and the whole space. This property can help identify connected spaces.

Ask a new question for Free

By Image

Drop file here or Click Here to upload

Math Problem Analysis

Mathematical Concepts

Topology
Clopen Sets
Discrete Topology
Indiscrete Topology
Connectedness

Formulas

-

Theorems

Properties of Clopen Sets
Connectedness of Topological Spaces

Suitable Grade Level

Undergraduate